Posts made by ydavid

@ncscswitch:

All IC’s limitted would be a VERY interesting game!  Would force Allies to spread out a bit, and would also put something other than INF on the board in Europe.

Unlimitted IC’s makes it so the Axis doesn;t ahve a prayer, period.  Just put a UK tank factory in Persia and a US tank factory in Sinkiang… game over for the Axis.

I agree wholeheartedly, if the US and UK put up an Asian Wall strategy with unlimited factories they could easily knock Japan off the mainland quickly. It wouldn’t help Germany or Russia really but once Finland/Norway fell, assuming it was either the US or UK…

This would kill the Axis

Hi all,

I just wanted to get everyone’s opinion about the best Allied strategy. The poll question is somewhat limited to the physical board game though, the factory limitation doesn’t exist in any pc based version I’ve ever played. I’ve found this to be a very good strategy because it slows Japan down (they’ll only be able to place 1 factory in Asia). Given Japan’s limited finances early on, and the counterattacks this makes possible in every game I’ve seen it used in the Allies are able to effectively gang up on Germany and knock them out before Japan has been able to advance down and take out the factories in India and Sinkiang. It also had the added benefit of slowing their advance into Russian territory, which allowed Russia to build up more than it might otherwise have been able.

Anyhow, I’m just curious where this falls into everyone’s ‘list’ of best Allied moves? Is it a top 10, top 5, top 3, useless, etc.

@El:

kyri,
I agree.  G buys most inf(maybe the C Med trn), with the occassional arm if ya got 2 additional IPCs. The arm G starts with should be good for 2-3 attacks so no need to go ARM HEAVY. Inf fodder needed with arm support so that if you have to lose it you don’t lose the ftrs(more flexible)!

Glad to see some more rational discussion. Taking out Russia in two turns - or 3 is not going to happen against a halfway decent player. Concentrating everything on Karelia leaves the Atlantic so open that the US and UK and start the shuck shuck by Round 3.

I think the best Germ option is to buy 9 inf and 1 arm on G1, and stick with roughly that purchase plan until it’s certain a knockout blow has been prepared for the USSR. In the meantime, hopefully Japan is making headway in Asia and can start to carve up Russian territory. However, if the Allies employ the Asian Wall strategy in conjunction with the purchase of all factory units (board limit) then this may take awhile. What’s nice about a heavy inf mix is that if the Axis is forced into a Fortress Europe strategy they’ve already got a lot of defensive units (though that’s normally a slow death plan).

@Minus:

Yes…it is an old version.

I guess I need to shop around for an updated version.

Thanks

There’s a patch which addresses the AI tendency to buy subs. You’ll have to hunt for it but it’s out there.

If you can get a copy of Iron Blitz cheap it may be worth your time. The AI isn’t really any better than Hasbro but at least there are interesting scenarios to play thru.

Glad to hear you liked the idea.

I don’t think fundraising is the way to go. I think you’d have to charge an outright registration fee for this. My basic idea would be to try and arrange a deal with a smaller hotel in Vegas and everyone interested registers for the event. Registration would cover the cost of their room, admission to the tourney, etc. Then tack a few bucks on for prize money, gifts, awards, whatever it was decided to give the winner.

@Janus1:

yes, what constitutes an insult? because what if i say something insulting to someone, as a joke, and they got it, but you didnt?

That was my point Janus. That’s why I said I would hope they’ll error on the side of caution and let ‘borderline’ stuff go. Generally it’s too subjective to be judged accurately, especially individual comments.

Jeez, I go on vacation and come back and the world changes :) It’s really pretty sad that a step like this is necessary. It may be hard at times to judge intent though, so I hope this is something done with a large degree of ‘safe side’ meaning erring on the side of the person who is doing the insulting, etc. Some stuff is pretty clear, but bad humor taken out of context could fall into this category.

Do you have an appeals process in mind for those who didn’t think they were being insulting/abusive, etc?

For me I won’t enjoy the game unless it’s competitive so those options are one and the same. Also, if it’s a competitive game I should learn something I can use later. All of that makes the game interesting, and therefore fun to me.

I think I’d have to put Alexander not dying near the top of the list. Then he could have come back and conquered Northern Europe…

Those are all back East though Chris. I’ve no interest in going that far, and the night life, etc of Vegas will keep my wife busy while I play- and provide something for me to do after I lose :)

No weapon I could own would protect me from the government if it wanted me dead. Certainly not my shotgun. Get real. Our army has Tanks. Stealth Fighters…

I agree LB. On the other hand, I’m trusting some of those who serve and took the oath to remember their oath is to the Constitution if the worst comes to pass. In other words, in the case of civil insurrection/civil war I expect an armed populace will be important as the military splits up and forms factions which end up heading the groups fighting the civil war.

In other words, when the shit really hits the fan there won’t be enough fancy/advanced weaponry to go around, being able to mobilize a few thousand people and arm them with rifles might be enough to control a territory…

I wouldn’t recommend a full blown convention or anything, but we could probably overrun one of the smaller places, maybe StarDust or WestWard Ho… All we need is a large playing area, or not so large depending on the number of people interested.

Plus those of us with families could find something for the the wife etc. to do as well.

I agree, my wife would never let me go to Vegas without her :), but she’d be happy playing slots somewhere while I geeked out over a board…

If you’d like to pass along the idea why don’t we see what kind of response we get. They’d probably want some sort of idea about the number of people interested.

I’d get rid of handguns and their ammo. Yeah crooks can still get them if they try hard enough but if the defense is “Bad guys might buy it on the black market” then we should just legalize everything.

I’m ok with a permit for other gun ownership so long as the only prereq for the permit is the completion of a firearms safety course and it doesn’t cost more than about $50. Frankly though, I don’t think it’s constitutional to limit the public’s access to military grade rifles, despite all the harm that can be done. Just my opinion, but I always thought the clear intent was to let the citizenry arm itself so that if it had to overthrow the gov it could, and to me that means full auto, mortars, etc your own home militia is supposed to be legal. On the other hand, pistols are only good for crime, so get rid of em.

How much gas would they need? Could they store it? Since the Coast Guard is good at stopping Cubans how would they get by them in greater numbers after traveling 10 times as far?

Also, the conditions are better, so would as many of them want to immigrate compared to Cuba?

Maybe they’re really good swimmers… :)

I think pot serves as too much of a gateway drug, even if the effects are overstated to legalize it.

I don’t doubt people would make considerable amounts of money running tourists to Cuba, or importing those (supposedly) fine cigars…

I think once Castro passes the time will have come to reexamine it. The embargo is pointless, we practice a policy of engaging China with business to open it up, why in the world would that not work with Cuba, which is smaller and in our ‘backyard’ so to speak?

Think of the tourist opportunities…

I think there’s also a Cuban advocacy group which wants a free Cuba. That probably helps refugees get asylum also. I do wonder though, after Castro passes what will happen, Cuba has been stable by in light of the US opposition to its continued status quo existence. Does it really deserve to still be banned?

They could do that now though so why aren’t they? I’m not sure where in the Caribbean it is, is it closer than Cuba or further away? Besides, doesn’t the Coast Guard do a pretty good job of stopping the boat refugees when compared to the border crossings with Mexico?