Axis & Allies .org Forums
    • Home
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Register
    • Login
    1. Home
    2. SuperbattleshipYamato
    3. Topics
    0% for April
    S
    • Profile
    • Following 19
    • Followers 6
    • Topics 237
    • Posts 5,742
    • Best 623
    • Controversial 0
    • Groups 4

    Topics created by SuperbattleshipYamato

    • S

      Soviet Plan Z

      World War II History
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      1
      0
      Votes
      1
      Posts
      201
      Views

      S

      We all know that actually trying to complete Plan Z would have been national suicide for Germany on many levels, militarily, economically, and psychologically.

      But what about the battleships called “Stalin’s republics”?

      There were plans to build 15 of them, each almost as large as as a Yamato or Montana class battleship, although with less firepower. Only four were laid down (and only one was more than 20% complete) when Germany invaded the Soviet Union. After the war, all were scrapped. A similar fate met the Kronshtadt battlecruisers before the war.

      Another naval project were the Stalingrad class battlecruisers. Originally designed before the war, the project was revived as aircraft carrier escorts after it. The project only advanced with Stalin’s backing, and his death led to all the ships being cancelled.

      Given that the Soviets only barely completed their Kirov class light cruisers and the struggle on the industry to build even a small part of Stalin’s republics, would it have been harder for the Soviets to build this fleet or for Germany to build Plan Z? And if the Soviets succeeded, what would the impact on the war have been?

      This probably assumes Germany doesn’t invade the Soviet Union until later.

    • S

      Two-Ocean Navy Act timeline

      World War II History
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      1
      0
      Votes
      1
      Posts
      171
      Views

      S

      Should the US continued to remain neutral, what ships would have been completed by early 1943? Thank you!

    • S

      When do you think Jean Bart would have been completed?

      World War II History
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      1
      0
      Votes
      1
      Posts
      98
      Views

      S

      This assumes that Germany hasn’t at invaded France yet.

    • S

      Could Japan have found the Daqing oil fields in Manchuria during World War 2?

      World War II History
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      7
      0
      Votes
      7
      Posts
      2.0k
      Views

      S

      @imperious-leader

      I think Japan still would have invaded the Soviet Union though, if the Second Sino-Japanese War continued (the oil embargo only really happened once they invaded Indochina).

      Other than that I agree with you. That would be curious alternate reality.

    • S

      How many Tachibana class escort ships be made with the first 30% of a Yamato class battleship?

      World War II History
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      1
      0
      Votes
      1
      Posts
      198
      Views

      S

      This assumes that the design of the ship existed at the time, of course.

    • S

      Another big question

      Axis & Allies 1914
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      7
      0
      Votes
      7
      Posts
      1.1k
      Views

      KrieghundK

      @the_good_captain said in Another big question:

      @krieghund follow on question that may be answered by the answer to the previous: if France enters Albania on French turn 1, does the territory and its IPC go to France while Italian pieces are activated in Albania?

      No. Everything goes to Italy. From the FAQ:

      Q. If the capital of a minor power aligned to my power is mobilized by a friendly power, who takes control of the territory?
      A. Your power does.

    • S

      Big question I’ve had for a very long time

      Axis & Allies 1914
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      3
      0
      Votes
      3
      Posts
      701
      Views

      S

      @krieghund

      Thank you a lot!

    • S

      How official and accurate are the games from Historical Board Gaming?

      Global War
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      4
      0
      Votes
      4
      Posts
      1.3k
      Views

      Imperious LeaderI

      @superbattleshipyamato Right. alot more complications introduces longer play. More areas means longer play, More units longer play. I wish their was a light 12 page version with only about 6-10 more units, not 60 more. The map would have about 60% less areas and play would take 2-3 hours but still be buckets of dice concept. That would be my wish plus dedicated piece sets or a version that used counters like nova games edition.

    • S

      How accurate is this?

      World War II History
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      5
      0
      Votes
      5
      Posts
      395
      Views

      S

      @winterwarrior

      The same website (maybe a different author) posted this as well:

      https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwjNmO_HjNH4AhV_D0QIHbzCCtgQFnoECAQQAQ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fnationalinterest.org%2Fblog%2Fbuzz%2Fwhat-your-history-teacher-told-you-about-maginot-line-wrong-77666&usg=AOvVaw1hj7GAXrzBK6miMV6kqtuI

      Thank you for responding!

    • S

      What if the Baltenflotte saw action?

      World War II History
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      1
      0
      Votes
      1
      Posts
      197
      Views

      S

      In late 1941, Germany formed the Baltenflotte, consisting of the battleship Tirpitz, pocket battleship Admiral Scheer, light cruisers Emden, Lepzig, Koln, and Nurnbeg, 3 destroyers, and a torpedo boat squarafron.

      It was disbanded some time later without seeing action, due to most Soviets ships heavily damaged.

      However, what if the Baltenflotte saw action in their original intention, to prevent a Soviet breakout into Sweden? How would such a naval encounter have occurred and what would be the absence of Tirpitz from the Western Front for a few months?

    • S

      Reformed cavalry army?

      World War II History
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      1
      0
      Votes
      1
      Posts
      165
      Views

      S

      Stalin apparently had ideas to recreate cavalry armies in 1942. How would Soviet performance have been affected (positively and negatively) if such an army were created instead of cavalry mechanised groups and tanks corps being the highest armoured unit?

    • S

      Full German motorisation instead?

      World War II History
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      1
      0
      Votes
      1
      Posts
      167
      Views

      S

      What if instead of creating tank (or panzer) formations, Germany concentrated on building more trucks (and some half-tracks although not enough can probably built for the whole army) to fully motorise their army? How would their performance during the war have changed?

    • S

      How to bookmark topics/postings (was: Is there a way to mark discussions that you like?)

      Website/Forum Discussion
      • tips&tricks • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      6
      0
      Votes
      6
      Posts
      904
      Views

      PantherP

      @superbattleshipyamato

      Thank you for the question. It definitely raises awareness of this feature.

    • S

      Looking for special books - Any help?

      World War II History
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      3
      1
      Votes
      3
      Posts
      313
      Views

      S

      @witt

      Thank you!

    • S

      Did this game do well financially?

      Axis & Allies & Zombies
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      18
      1
      Votes
      18
      Posts
      2.9k
      Views

      M

      @domanmacgee No, No. That i know. The King and Kaisers Rules.

      1914 has very expensive prices in Germany. I wait for Renegade Games.

    • S

      What’s all this about?

      Global War
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      2
      0
      Votes
      2
      Posts
      686
      Views

      S

      @superbattleshipyamato Honestly, you’d be better off looking the different Global Wars up on YouTube. Lots of great channels out there, and tons of comprehensive videos.

    • S

      Is it more accurate?

      War Room
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      6
      0
      Votes
      6
      Posts
      1.4k
      Views

      S

      @domanmacgee

      Thank you for reaponding!

    • S

      On this date, something awesome happened!

      General Discussion
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      5
      2
      Votes
      5
      Posts
      620
      Views

      S

      @nolimit

      I know, but I’m not at the lectern, so no money involved.

    • S

      German Somua S35s

      World War II History
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      1
      0
      Votes
      1
      Posts
      200
      Views

      S

      I wonder if it would have been a better idea for Germany to fix the problems of this tank and produce them instead of the Panzer 3 and 4. Would this have been better for Germany? Thank you!

    • S

      How would they have done?

      World War II History
      • • • SuperbattleshipYamato
      5
      2
      Votes
      5
      Posts
      396
      Views

      S

      @abworsham4

      Awesome! So again, who do you think will win?

    • 1
    • 2
    • 8
    • 9
    • 10
    • 11
    • 12
    • 10 / 12