Axis & Allies .org Forums
    • Home
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Register
    • Login
    1. Home
    2. Narvik
    3. Best
    • Profile
    • Following 0
    • Followers 0
    • Topics 24
    • Posts 1,038
    • Best 259
    • Controversial 0
    • Groups 1

    Best posts made by Narvik

    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      UK TURN 23 - SPRING 1945

      OPERATION UNTHINKABLE
      Winston consider backstabbing Stalin and attack the Red Army in Germany to save Poland.
      Patton agree.
      Truman rule out the operation as military unfeasible.

      The Arab League is formed in Cairo.

      The king of kings, Reza Pahlavi of Persia, demands all UK and USSR troops leave Persia ASAP!!!

      King Ibn Saud (Saudi Arabia) and Johan (Norway) DOW Tokyo Kid

      537731425_742881978609286_6949711606280789786_n.jpg
      From left: king Farouk, Truman, Pahlavi, Winston, Johan, Ibn and Tokyo Kid far right.

      PURCHASE
      CV, 2 Air, 2 FTR, 2 BMB

      COMBAT

      UK: 1 BMB SBR> Nor = total damage
      UK: 2 BMB SBR> W. Ge: = total damage
      UK: 2 BMB attack> sz 113: sink all remaining ships

      INVASION OF WESTERN GERMANY
      Holl/Belg: 4 Inf, 3 Art, Tank attack> W. Ge: 2 Fort, 2 Blockhouses, 4 Inf, AA, 2 FTR
      UK: 2 Trannies to sz 110 + 2 Inf + 2 Inf (CAN) amp> W. GE
      Loss Ge: all units

      NON-COMB MOVE
      Adolf give up and all Axis forces in Denmark and Norway surrender.
      UK, Tranny w Inf to sz 112 + offload in Nor
      UK: Tranny w Inf to sz 112 + offload in Den

      538636600_742882328609251_3057320390175721285_n.jpg

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      ITALY TURN 23 - SPRING 1945
      Musso and Clara is hanged.
      Adolf and Eva commit suicide
      Two of the main Axis players have left the game

      The new Italian player, Badoglio DOW Tokyo Kid

      COMBAT

      BATTLE OF POLJANA
      Yugo: 2 Inf (Partisan) attack> Slovenia/Trieste: Inf (GE) + Inf (Serb)
      Loss Axis: all units + 100 000 serbs, croats and cossacks is massacred
      Because Trieste was UK responsibility, Tito is now in conflict with Winston.
      This was the last official battle in Europe, but because France is last in the Turn order, The Second Battle of the Alps will be the last battle in this Blog

      537731036_742895511941266_4290905195882387761_n.jpg

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      ANZAC AND UK PAC TURN 23 - SPRING 1945

      COMBAT
      BATTLE OF MALACCA STRAIT
      Ceylon: DD attack> sz 37: CA
      Loss JAP: all units

      NON-COMB MOVE
      sz 41: CV, BB, CA, DD to sz 19

      538115230_742896431941174_7146389880806147404_n.jpg

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      FRANCE TURN 23 - SPRING 1945

      Jodl signs the unconditional surrender at Reims, France.
      Stalin is not present.

      de Gaulle DOW Badoglio because he want to grab a piece of Italy

      537432919_742898218607662_6664645365545523010_n.jpg

      PURCHASE
      2 Inf, Art

      COMBAT
      SECOND BATTLE OF THE ALPS
      S. It: Inf, Tank, FTR attack> N. It: Inf (IT)
      Loss IT: all units
      Truman is not happy and stop de Gaulle.

      NON-COMB MOVE

      THE SELIFA MASSACRE IN ALGERIA
      Alg: Inf murder 40 000 civilians

      537913720_742898525274298_8922338638757713723_n.jpg

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      ROUND 24 (june july aug 1945) the final round
      GERMANY TURN 24 - SUMMER 1945

      POTSDAM CONFERENCE - TERMINAL
      The Allied Control Council takes power and supreme autorothy of Germany.
      De Gaulle resist this Agreement. Germany belongs to France now.

      Stalin, Truman and Winston also demand unconditional surrender of Japan.

      Also a lot of Axis war criminals are arrested: left on the pic

      537737418_743606768536807_5887684532809272817_n.jpg

      The situation in Europe after the war

      537644023_743607205203430_1540697325248540233_n.jpg

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      USSR TURN 24 - SUMMER 1945

      Stalin (USSR) and Choibalsan (Mongolia) DOW Tokyo Kid (Japan)

      PURCHASE
      3 FTR, 3 TAC, 6 Tanks, 2 Inf, 2 Art

      COMBAT

      SOVJET-JAPAN WAR
      Amur: 8 Inf, 8 Art, 7 Tanks + 2 FTR, 2 TAC, BMB attack> Manchuria: 6 Inf, Art, Tank, FTR, TAC, 3 Inf Manchuko
      Loss USSR: Inf, Tank + Loss JAP: all units

      Amur: 7 Inf + 3 FTR, TAC attack> North Korea: 4 Inf, 2 FTR
      Loss JAP: all units

      538205551_743613065202844_6142644447835911975_n.jpg

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      JAPAN TURN 24 - SUMMER 1945

      Tokyo Kid rejects the Potsdam Declaration.

      PURCHASE
      2 FTR, Inf

      NON-COMB MOVE
      Siam: 2 Inf (JA) + Inf (Siam) + Inf (Free India) to Shan State

      COLLECT INCOME CONVOY DISRUPTION
      4 Subs in sz 6 = loss 11 IPC
      US Fleet in sz 19 = loss 9 IPC
      2 Subs in sz 20 = loss 5 IPC
      total loss = 25 IPC

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      USA TURN 24 - SUMMER 1945

      UN Charter signed in San Francisco

      Truman approves the use of A-Bomb in Japan

      TECH
      Trinity test in New Mexico - first a-bomb ever,

      PURCHASE
      East: CA, 3 FTR, TAC, 3 BMB
      Okinava: Airbase

      COMBAT

      OPERATION MATTERHORN
      Iwo: BMB SBR> Jap = total damage
      Oki: BMB SBR> Jap; = total damage
      Guam: BMB SBR> Jap: = total damage

      OPERATION CENTERBOARD
      Marianas: H. BMB nuke> Jap: = total damage

      TF 58: 8 CV, 16 Air, 2 BB, 5 CA, 5 DD attack> sz 6: DD, 5 Trannis + FTR scrambled
      Loss Jap: all units
      8 cv-Air SBR> Jap: Naval Base = total damage

      sz 22: CA to sz 21: Sub (Jap)
      Loss US: CA Indianapolis sunk

      2 Trannies to sz 6 + 2 inf, Art amp> South Korea: contestet territory with USSR
      This was the beginning of a divided Korea and later the Korean War

      15. august - Tokyo Kid surrender

      538915390_743622958535188_3936331490710310240_n.jpg

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      CHINA TURN 24 - SUMMER 1945

      Chiang and Mao meet in Chongqing. This start the civil war.

      Ho Chi Minh start an uprising in French Indo China, now named Vietnam.

      Sukarno start an uprising in Indonesia (Java) and declare independence from Holland

      PURCHASE
      KMT 1 Inf
      CCP 5 Inf
      Vietnam: Inf
      Java: 2 Inf

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      UK TURN 24 - SUMMER 1945

      Winston resign, Attlee new UK player.

      King is re-elected as the Canada player

      UK take over Syria and Lebanon from France

      British Somaliland: Sheik Bashir start a rebellion against UK rule

      NURENBERG TRIALS BEGIN

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      ITALY TURN 24 - SUMMER 1945

      Tito back down. Trieste (town in Italy) is not worth a new world war.

      NON-COMB MOVE
      N: It: 2 Inf (Yugo) to Yugo

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      ANZAC AND UK PAC TURN 24 - SUMMER 1945

      Aus: Curtin dies in office. Ben is the new ANZAC player

      Subas Bose, the Free India player, is assassinated

      Tokyo Kid signs the surrender abord USS Missouri in sz 6.
      D. MacArthur is supreme commander in Japan.

      539323765_743642505199900_8218671423499253536_n.jpg
      Unfortunately I miss a MacArthur figurine so Patton step in. Will edit later
      Martha Gellhorn and Capa far right
      Also the cleaners have startet to put away the game. Next holiday this basement will be used for the A&A 1914 game. But that will be another Blog

      COMBAT
      OPERATION CAPITAL
      India: 4 Inf, Art, Tank (UK) + 4 Inf (Pun) + Inf (Gur) attack> Shan State: 2 Inf (JA), Inf (Siam), Inf (Free)
      Loss Axis: all units

      Tranny to sz 43 + Inf (UK) Inf (ANZ) amp> Borneo; Inf
      Loss Jap: all units

      BATTLE OF SURABAYA
      TF 37: CA, DD, Tranny to sz 42 + Inf (UK), Inf (ANZ) amp> Java: 2 Inf (Indonesia)
      Loss Indonesia: all units

      537702082_743642908533193_5757131546851031606_n.jpg

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      FRANCE TURN 24 - SUMMER 1945

      Charles de Gaulle become PRESIDENT of France for job well done

      537731425_743663721864445_8516752367482454144_n.jpg

      Winners of the A&A Global 1939 Tournament game is:
      The Allied Team: Clement, Truman, Stalin and Chiang- the Big Four

      539451987_743664075197743_1698079025810518019_n.jpg

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @Narvik

      How risky was the real WW II game for the players?

      Lets look into the 9 playable powers:

      3 players died in Round 23, all in april 1945.
      Adolf, the german player, commited suicide because he lost the game.
      Benito, the italian player, was hanged because he lost the game.

      FDR was winning the game, but died of natural causes just before cashing in. An intriguing fact is that if Wendell Willkie had won the election, and become the US player, he too died during the game, in Round 21, oct 1944. So either way a vice had to finish the game. In this case Truman.

      Also two ANZAC players died in office during the game. Michael Savage died in Round 3 and John Curtin in Round 24, the last round. ANZAC was played by 6 different players, starting with “Pig Iron Bob” Menzies and finishing with Ben and Fraser.

      The first UK player, Neville Chamberlain, resigned in Round 3 and died in Round 5.
      The most famous UK player, Winston, resigned in Round 24, the last round, and was replaced in the Victory Parade by Clement Attlee. Now that must have been disappointing to Winnie.

      None of the 5 french players died but 4 of them was arrested and spent some time in prison.
      Both Daladier and Reynauld were locked up at Itter Castle prison already in Round 4.
      Petain and Pierre Laval got locked op in Round 21 for switching to the Axis.
      de Gaulle would pop up and play France the last round, rejecting the Allied victory and keep a solo game going in the old french colonies all over the world.

      Of the main 9 players only Stalin, Tokyo Kid and Chiang would play from Round 1 to the final Round 24.

      Of the minor neutral non-playable powers, a lot of players would be arrested after the game, for being war criminals. Others would be assassinated during play.

      Poland, the first to fight, lost 2 great players:
      Ryds-Smigly in round 10 and Sikorsky in round 16.

      Metaxa, playing Greece, was possible poisoned in round 6.
      Tsar Boris III, playing Bulgaria, was possible poisoned in round 16.
      Stauning, playing Denmark, died in round 11.
      Ulmanis, playing one of the Baltic States, died in GULAG in round 13, and Smedina in round 21.
      Szalasi, playing Hungary, was hanged in round 23.
      Quisling, who tried to play Norway unofficial after the worlds first solo coup by a radio speech, and with no back up what so ever, and even during a german attack, in wich the german player Adolf nor any of his officers was prepared for this, is hanged in round 23.

      In China, the ROC- player Wang Jingwei is killed in round 21. The other puppet players to Japan, Prince De and emperor Puyi, spent some time in GULAG, but survive a short time after round 24.
      KMT-player Chiang survive round 24, but are soon to be replaced by Mao, playing CCP.

      The dominion players Will King, playing Canada, and Smuts, playing South Africa, are in the game from round 1 to round 24. Now that pretty much sums it up. Hopeful we won’t see this much drama on a Con, a Turnament game in our basement with casual friends.

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @DoManMacgee

      Thank you so much for taking time to go through and liking this blog. I guess we both love history.

      I can’t take credit for the idea. The Classic A&A MB edition was publised in 1984, and from 1995 online homepages on the WWW had become common. I remember there were lots of homepages about A&A, like Don’s Essays and Thrasher, and a dude made a blog almost exactly like this, but with MB Classic and start in 1942 and each Round was 6 months. It was so well done. Unfortunately I can’t find it, it’s propably lost. I loved it so much I wanted to do the same. Now his blog was really well done, and my blog is just the beta test. I was hoping for some discussion and feedback before I make my homepage. So far I understand that I have to make better pics. To represent historical events visually is important. Nobody read a lot of text.

      Again, thanks for giving me feedback

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @DoManMacgee Oh no, it’s not finished, it’s in progress. I need to figure out the Collect Income too, and that is not easy. We have the GDP that change all the time, and also the Military Outlays change from month to month. I don’t even know for sure how many aircrafts were made because the estimates differ from source to source. Some say US made 30 000 aircrafts but no more than 2000 were operational at any time, so where did all the planes go? And the estimates of casualties on the Eastern Front differ one million men give or take. In my Blog that is like 10 Infantry. I can’t make an accurate historical correct Blog if I don’t know the correct numbers.

      This Blog have surprisingnly many wievs but not so much diskussion. Lets look into how I solved the US entry. In the real war Japan dow’ed USA, and then Germany dow’ed USA some days after. But the Turn order in A&A, which I follow strictly, is Germany, Japan, USA. Also a dow should be made in that players turn. That left me with a few choices:

      -Round 10 winter 1941/42. Jap dow US. Next US attack Germany. Round 11 spring: Germany dow USA. Now attacking nazis is not bad, but this was not historically correct. Germany did in fact dow USA before strict neutral USA started attacking the Axis.

      to solve this I could let Germany dow USA in Round 9 fall. Also not historically correct, since in fact Japan dow’ed USA before Germany dow’ed USA. A very importent point is that Japan would’nt dow anyone before the german attack on Moscow was resolved. IF success Japan would attack USSR far east, but if failure Japan would attack USA.

      To change the Turn order was never even considered. That would mess up everything.

      My solution was, as you know, to let all Axis players dow USA simultaneously on Japans turn. My rational for this is the Berlin Pact, signed in Berlin september 1940 by Germany, Italy and Japan, and later the other Axis, and this pact was an agreement to dow USA all toghether at the same time. One for all, all for one. I don’t see any other way to do it. A slight violation of the OOB rules yes, but also the less of many evils. But I am surprised it was no questions. All wievers just accepted my solutin. I miss that kind of discussions. I guess you have to be a super nerd of a history buff to engage in that. And I figure the casual A&A players are not. They just want a good time playing a board game

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @DoManMacgee Thank you for feedback. Much appreciated.

      As we speak I’m working on a WWI Blog, and also the new A&A Stalingrad game, and reading books about WWII economy, so this blog will not be edited anytime soon. I also have OCD when it comes to accuracy and prefection, so I need time.

      I actually did consider using the HBG map, but had to turn it down for several reasons. First, HBG is fanbased and not official. I want to use the official A&A maps, pieces and rules as far as possible. Also, living in Europe I am not aware of legal issues when using stuff from other companies in Blogs. It feels more safe to stay to the official A&A franchise. I’m not rich and can’t afford a law suet (spelling? English is not my first language) Also I’m conserned bout the visuals. The A&A maps looks good. I don’t like the glossy colors on the HBG maps. Most of all I want to mix the A&A 1914 and the A&A 1940 global maps, somehow, But again, legal issues? I can do so much in my basement with friends, but an official Blog? I dunno man.

      The problem with “in-game rules” or OOB (out of box) rules, is, as far as I am conserned, I don’t love them. This rules are designed for game balance, playability and ease of play. My 5 years as soldier and studying military history for 40 years, make my stomach turn upside down when reading the rules. Very few of the rules make sense. Take the new Stalingrad game. Now that was a missed opportuinity. A regional map with plain steppe terrain perfect for maneuver warfare with Blitzkrieg, Deep operations, breakthroughs, flanking, hit and run, and a city map with urban warfare, and the designer ruined it. Both maps have typically trench warfare and attrition. I love the supply rule, and units beeing out of supply when encircled and under siege, just as in a real war, but for some reason the designer ruined all the possibilities. We can only fix it with a lot of House Rules. And that is what I am working on as we speak.

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @DoManMacgee you were a playtester OMG I have so many questions. Will make a thread in the Stalingrad forum soon, but just mention very fast, since we are doing this anyway, a few years ago there was this talk 'bout streamlining the rules for all A&A games, both global and theater games. That has not been done. North Africa and Stalingrad got very different rules. Now that was a missed opportunity. Why a new supply-rule? Now we have 3 different supply rules, one for Bulge, another for N.A and yet another for Stalingrad. Also all games are scripted. The old D-day game was the worst, so boring to play. I get it if you are playing competetiv in Tournaments and want a fast game, fast to set up, fast to play. But 99% don’t play competetiv. We, the people, are die-hards plastic piece junkies with a military power fantasy. The beauty of the classic A&A MB 1984 edition was it was not scripted. Anything would go. German battleship in Indian Ocean? Sure, why not. A&A should not be Memory Game the historically correct re-enactment simultasion. Ok, enough rant, will make threat in Stalingrad forum soon

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • RE: Blog: The grand Strategy Game.

      @DoManMacgee I agree so far. I don’t play Tournaments so at some point we will not agree. But basically all versions of A&A should be easy to learn. A&A is not a hex and counter game. I miss the Classic Rulebook, it was 4 pages if I remember correct.

      Lets take the Road Movement rule. In North Africa anything with wheels can move 5 spaces on a road. I love it. But in Stalingrad only Tanks and Mech can move 2 spaces and 2 additional spaces if they start at a road, but Assault guns and Rocket Launchers can not move 2 additional spaces. Now that don’t make sense since the Panzer III and the Stug III had the same range and the same speed limit. And also the ZIS 42 halftrack was the excact same as the ZIS 42 Rocket Launcer. I guess its because of game balance. But for playability all motorized vehicles should be able to Road Movement. So this rule beats me for sure.

      I also noticed there are 6 spaces between Grain elevator and Tractor Factory. So it takes a Tank 3 Rounds to move between those points. A Round is 2 weeks. So it takes 6 weeks to drive 15 miles, or 25 km. I am awere it was a lot of rubble and debris in the streets of Stalingrad, but I walk 15 miles, or 25 km, on my feet in 'bout 3 hours. OK, lets give this to game balance and playability, it’s just a game after all. But it does bother me.

      I need to start posting in the Stalingrad Forum. Hoper you have some inputs.

      posted in Blogs
      NarvikN
      Narvik
    • 1
    • 2
    • 9
    • 10
    • 11
    • 12
    • 13
    • 13 / 13