Posts made by majikforce

@avner Okay. GG.

@bolasgod

Ger 6.tsvg

@aagamerz13

Rus 12.tsvg

@farmboy said in 21 Playoff BM Farmboy+20 vs Majikforce:

@majikforce said in 21 Playoff BM Farmboy+20 vs Majikforce:

@farmboy I have no problem with that. But there is an issue. I do believe you cannot amphib assault a territory from two different sea zones. So either all the transports have to be in sz 91 or the one from Canada is a NCM . Doesn’t really change anything since the dice rolls were well in your favor either way. Just thought you should know the rule for future situations.

I can certainly do that on the future and at least it wasn’t a battle where this could change the outcome. But are you sure that is the rule? I don’t see that in the rules(although I might have missed it) and I haven’t had this come up in play before. Although I suppose there are not many zones where it could happen.

Well I guess I am crazy because I couldn’t find it either. I swear I remember reading that somewhere at some point. Bu t it was probably years ago. Oh well never mind my delusions. Game on!

@farmboy Ita 3.tsvg

@farmboy I have no problem with that. But there is an issue. I do believe you cannot amphib assault a territory from two different sea zones. So either all the transports have to be in sz 91 or the one from Canada is a NCM . Doesn’t really change anything since the dice rolls were well in your favor either way. Just thought you should know the rule for future situations.

@avner So we have an issue to come to an agreement about. When you assumed no scramble when you attacked Denmark I actually would of scrambled one plane to cause the sz to be hostile thereby not allowing you to be able to use the transports to NCM the tanks into Norway.

I am not sure if you were aware of this rule or just forgot. But since it was your mistake I propose we roll for my fighter and your attacking navy and air force, edit the results accordingly and then you can adjust your NCM moves for US and UK but the tanks must move back to Normandy. Let me know what you think.

@bolasgod

Ita 5.tsvg

@simon33 Thanks. That’s what I was thinking as well. Now the question is how do I handle this fairly since my opponent didn’t ask for a scramble and maybe didn’t know the rule. Re-doing the whole turn is tricky because the UK already went as well.

Rules Question?

The US has a Navy in sz112 with 8 transports. They amphib assault denmark with 1 transport going to sz 110 to pick up 2inf from Normandy and then unload in sz 112 for denmark. I have German scramble options.

Question #1 After the amphib with no scramble can the US use the 7 leftover transports to NCM move troops from Normandy to Norway

Question #2 If there was a scramble can the US still do the same move as stated above.

I guess bottom line is can the unused transports still move in NCM since they were part of an amphib assault in the sz or does a scramble need to trigger them not being able to move?

@martin Click too fast. Meant to stop attacking in Hopei after my Inf was killed. I edited back the mech and my Bomber. Let me know if you do not accept the edit and we can change it back.

Jap 7.tsvg

@bolasgod

Jap 5.tsvg

@farmboy

Jap 3.tsvg

@aagamerz13 Yep it is affecting everyone. You will just have to manually attach a saved game file. Follow one of the links above that panther posted if you need help with that.

@farmboy
Ger 3.tsvg

@avner
Jap 19.tsvg

@martin

Ger 7.tsvg

@bolasgod Yep its working.

@Martin Italy 6.tsvg

@bolasgod Forum is having posting issues. Game file is attached.
Ger 5.tsvg