Axis & Allies .org Forums
    • Home
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Register
    • Login
    1. Home
    2. ksmckay
    3. Best
    0%
    K
    • Profile
    • Following 0
    • Followers 2
    • Topics 41
    • Posts 6,785
    • Best 116
    • Controversial 0
    • Groups 1

    Best posts made by ksmckay

    • RE: League General Discussion Thread

      @regularkid said in League General Discussion Thread:

      @ksmckay perhaps I misunderstood. I thought the problem was that the “default” game of for the playoffs was out of line with what a majority of people prefer to play (which is solved by making the default game the one that most people play). What I’m saying is that one championship is preferable to three, even if you maintain separate statistics for each version of the game.

      Its been a long discussion and while I personally agree with that approach, there are dissenting arguments with merit and so the latest proposal by gamerman is a compromise.

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: L21 Amon-Sul (Axis) vs Pejon_88 (Allies + 16)

      @pejon_88 @Amon-Sul

      the trick in the pacific is to put a UK dd in same sea zone as japanese transports, and then DOW with Anzac. You need two powers to make it work as if you tried to do it with UK alone, you would be at war with Japan when you tried to move a dd to the japanese sz. Rarely works out though since the cost for anzac declaring war on Japan is so high. But sometimes it works out if Japanese player forgets to preload transports on J2.

      Dont really think there is a similar trick in europe. Italy and Germany declare war on Russia independently and a state of war between one doesnt affect the other.

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: L21 Amon-Sul (Axis) vs Pejon_88 (Allies + 16)

      @pejon_88

      Yep, those are both right, I thought you were talking about how to get around that rule. And the anzac trick is the only way to get around that.

      Wasnt always the case with global and before the rule was changed it was really gamey.

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: League General Discussion Thread

      @regularkid said in League General Discussion Thread:

      @gamerman01 said in League General Discussion Thread:

      point being, there are ways to not make the champion of a small pond look equal to the champion of the ocean

      Well its not so much about that. Rather, I think playoffs generate excitement, in part, because people want the singular title of “league champion.” One big, end of year event for the entire community. Rather than balkanized proceedings.

      Unfortunately you would have to read through a couple hundred posts to get a picture of the entire argument. The new proposal does its best to include every potential player’s desires whereas what you are saying (similar to what we have now) excludes some preferences. If we just changed to BM default, then that would exclude people who prefer OOB (even if thats a small number in this community, it still excludes them).

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: 2020 Playoff AndrewAAGamer (X) vs JDOW (L+58) OOB

      @jdow You should make sure to install whatever version Andrew is using. If you mix versions that can cause problems.

      Issues with calculators and rules seem to be map and version specific. One version might work ok with one map but then not work with another map. So you might have just run into this problem because you are running a new map for this game (OOB).

      Also, updating the client wont fix anything. If you start a game with one version and switch versions the problems will migrate. Only way to fix if you are having problems is to move to a client without issues and restart the game. (easy to do since you are only halfway thru first round).

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: 20 Playoffs BM3 Majik vs WindowWasher +20

      @windowwasher there is an autosave folder that deals with that kind of mistake. look in your tripleA folder for a folder called saved games. autosaves for every power at all kinds of critical junctures such as end of turn.

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: 2020 Championship: axis-dominion vs ksmckay (+22)

      @oysteilo sounds like you have it all figured out, not certain why you bothered asking a question, I’m sorry for responding.

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: Post League Game Results Here

      Axis Dominion (axis) over ksmckay (allies +22) in League Championship. Well played and well deserved. Congrats!

      https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/37554/2020-championship-axis-dominion-vs-ksmckay-22/289

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: L21 #2 Martin (X) vs trulpen (A+30) OOB

      @martin Competitive games never see a MIC in romania. So thats the first clue. If you do find a game where one was used despite its shortcomings, it was probably used to buy inf closer to the front immediately. You spent 30 ipcs in Rd 3 and got zero value from it in the game. You didnt really use it much early on and when did use it you bought mech. You could have just as easily used the 30 ipcs to buy mech to deploy in Germany and then just bought mech in subsequent turns.

      Just a huge waste of money early on which slows your push on russia and allows them to build an overwhelming force which you wont ever push through.

      Your G1 was pretty suspect and pretty much set the tone for a rough game in europe. I would try a more conventional opening. A lot of ground losses on G1 where ground losses are really bad for germany early on. No reason to attack SFr and Normandy. Dont dilute the attack on Paris. And given the choice between 110 and 111 always go 110. Germany bought navy and still left UK the option to buy an airfield and a factory without consequence - devastating for axis. I didnt look at all, but saw a lot of troubling signs in G1-G3 and axis cant afford a slow start.

      Didnt look at anything else but those mistakes are hard to overcome.

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: 21 BM3 playoff Ksmckay(x) vs Surfer(A+21)

      @surfer said in 21 BM3 playoff Ksmckay(x) vs Surfer(A+21):

      @ksmckay I’m not sure what your policy is towards edits…I don’t mind edits that change NCM as long as they are made before the opponent’s move.
      Regardless, I forgot to move the AA to Queensland and made edit.

      pretty flexible for anything reasonable. I dont think anyone could ever deny this.

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: bm4 axis-dominion vs farmboy (+19)

      @farmboy said in bm4 axis-dominion vs farmboy (+19):

      @axis-dominion if the Soviets attack Kansu, it would negate the Soviet Mongolian pact because Kansu is now Japanese occupied and adjacent right. I’m pretty sure it happens on both sides of Mongolia and not just Korea/Manchuria but want to be sure.

      FYI, it doesnt matter that Kansu was japanese. Even if it was still owned by china, moving in would negate the pact (and would also have required a DOW by Russian on Japan)

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: 21 BM3 playoff Ksmckay(x) vs Surfer(A+21)

      @surfer gonna change inf alignment in Italy. hold please

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: 21 BM3 playoff Ksmckay(x) vs Surfer(A+21)

      @surfer Please take your time and figure things out and let me know when you are ready. Im slow during the week so no rush. as far as tripleA post error, doesnt sound like this but just in case, sometimes it gets swtiched to tripleA forums and then you get a funny error, so just check forum settings in file and lets get it sorted.

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: 21 BM3 playoff Ksmckay(x) vs Surfer(A+21)

      @surfer whether or not this was the optimal play in the pacific I dont know, but I would say that the first move was not a good move.

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: 21 BM3 playoff Ksmckay(x) vs Surfer(A+21)

      @surfer should be an autosave in tripleA/SavedGames/Autosave/ saves after almost every phase (movements/battles/etc) of the game. so no reason to redo things.

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • RE: L21 SF trulpen (X) vs ksmckay (A+21) BM4

      @trulpen said in L21 SF trulpen (X) vs ksmckay (A+21) BM4:

      Ah, yes, meant to ask about a thing.

      I unfortunately have a serious health issue/illness which might impact my possibility to visit here.

      I’ll try my best to be quick in my responses, but because of this I’d appreciate if we skip the bump-rules. The 21-day rule of claiming a win by abscence should be ok to keep.

      Keeping the bumps can initiate some stress, but hopefully it won’t. It’s mainly a friendly request on my part and you may decide upon it.

      I wont bump if you disappear. If you are posting in other games and not this one, I will. Seems reasonable to me but let me know if its not.

      posted in League
      K
      ksmckay
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3
    • 4
    • 5
    • 6
    • 6 / 6