I have to agree with IL on the quality of games. I just find COD 1 & 2 to be everything I dreamed of. However, I wouldn’t discredit BIA and MOH.
MOH definitely set the tone and was great in its time. COD just came along and did it better, plus a few bonuses (iron sights, graphics, playability, etc….) I’d say COD also has the best AI and “fluff” (sounds, dying animations, level design, etc.)
I have to give praise to BIA, though. Its better for realism, and the strategy of squad combat makes the replay value go up. Not to mention the story is good and multiplayer is fresh with so many options - you can be the Joes or Jerries. I’d recommend it CC, but don’t neglect Call of Duty. Both have non-stop action, but if you want to think a bit more, go with BIA.
By the way, IL, I just got a not-so-legal version of COD2 to test it on my laptop. Runs b-e-a-u-t-i-f-u-l, so I’ll pick up the real thing soon a get with you online. I love the tweaks they made to the weapons, and glad they left the BA-mfin’-R true to the 1st game.