Vote 1: Ark Royal
Vote 2 : IndomitableArk Royal is (in my opinion) to the British as the Yorktowns are to the Americans: good design, hardy, fleet duty, veterans of famous engagements. If any carrier would be essential for the British, it would have to be Ark Royal. Followed closely by Illustrious.
Malta is a great choice, if logical, since it is analogous to the Midway-class.
So will the Brits get 3 carrier types, like the other nations? Light/Escort - Fleet/Standard - Heavy/Advanced … Though I think the Americans currently have 4 carrier sculpts on the docket.
Light    Furious   = Casablanca
Fleet    Ark Royal  = Yorktown
Fleet    Illustrious = Essex
Heavy    Malta    = MidwayI would actually like to see an HBG version of Illustrious, but if that should be reserved for a basic OOB replacement set, to come at a later date, then that is great.
Since HBG offers a CVE for the UK color (Casablanca) we will do the Ark Royal and Malta for the 2 other class carriers. We will come back and do other carriers at a later date. Thanks for all the input.