Posts made by gsh34

Well, that has to take the cake.  You didn’t even commandeer an existing room.  You built an entire new room! :-o :-o :-o  Now who is going to try to top that!

Bob,

You are pretty good at catching these map anomalies.  Can you write a master list for me and post it.  I would like to have one place to check for the changes needed.

FYI, it will still be a several weeks before I’m done.  Since I’m new to photoshop, every challenge I encounter usually takes me a while to figure out.  One thing in particular that I’m having issues with is trying to balance the colors of the Euro maps with the Pacific map panels.  Right now that is not going so well.

Bob,

I think the reason for putting Honolulu on the Big Island where Hilo is was because it is totally disproportionate to Oahu.  Take a look and see what I mean.  I can move it easily enough if that is still what you like.  To me, both the current placement and the correct one bug me for different reasons.

edit:  On second thought, I probably will move it.  The VC dot is disproportionately large compared to the size of Oahu, but it does look better to be in the correct position.

Yeah, I’ve been to Hawaii (both Oahu and the Big Island) and I wondered why Honolulu was placed on the Big Island.  I’ll give it a whirl and see how it looks when I move it.

@Imperious:

Where is the Europe part?

In the garbage. :-o  I didn’t like how the panels were being stitched together so I came at the project a different way and I started on the Pacific side of the board.  I still need to do the Europe boards.

See first post for update.

I had completely forgotten about that 10/50 ipc icon on the W. US.  I’ve ignored it since day one.  It is now corrected on my map and will be included in future updates.  I’ll be looking into updating the “convoy” and “kamikazi” markers so that they are more visible, but not too much so.  The color by the one I had in Hawaii was sampled from the sea zone numbers.  I’ll see if I can’t try a few different color varieties for the next post and see what people think.

@JamesAleman:

I’ve brought the Bell-Fey expression into my gaming group. Soon the Midwest will know the term and you can look for it on local news channels…for instance, weathermen might say, I guess that it is not going to snow after all, I guess I Bell-Feyed that forecast. :)

Excellent expansion of the word.  I can see powerful forces are already at working taking this expression (a “Belfay”) and expanding it to other fields.

I would propose that it could be used in sports also.  Such as the Chicago Bears pulling a “Belfay” in the NFC Championship game by not really showing up to play Green Bay.

We’ve done weather and sports, who else can help to embed the term “pulled a Belfay” into pop culture?  Anyone have ins with Lady Gaga?

Dave

@bellefeuille:

Having read many of the comments, I conclude that allowing one’s team mate to “bell fey” is nearly as culpable as “bell feying” one’s self.

Based on this observation I want to point out a couple things:

1. The Bell Fey only applies to island nations (Japan and UK).
2. In our group we only permit a maneouver to be given a name when repeated (must happen twice).
3. A certain party in our group (who seems fond of broadcasting the Bell-fey) far and wide has managed to Lose Germany under similar circumstances: leaving skeleton forces in UK’s way and then not being able to retake Denmark to close the straits because of the interceding French Cruiser.  And in a subsequent game letting his partner lose Germany to the Russian Transport.

My questions are:

1. Does letting your partner “Pooch” Germany and “pooching” Germany yourself meet our group’s criteria that you must “Pooch twice” to have a move named for you?
2. I propose that the appropriate name for this German form of the “Bell-Fey” would be the “Robbie”?

Comprising 1/2 of the Axis and Allies National Nomenclature Committee (Mr. Bunnell being the other half), I can say that the “Belfay” entered the lexicon in 2004 with the Revised ed.  It is defined as: The leaving open of one’s capital such that one ground unit takes it uncontested.

While Japan was most often on the receiving end of the “Belfay” move due to missing transport movements, it is clearly not a move restricted to islands just because Japan is an island.

I hope this helps to clear up any confusion on what exactly constitutes “pulling a Belfay”.

Thank you,
Dave
1/2 of the Axis and Allies National Nomenclature Committee

See my first post.  I’ve edited and updated it.

About the Portuguese Guinea map fold–I don’t know how to get rid of it exactly.  The word “Guinea” is in the fold.  I’m totally new to Photoshop and as of yet, I don’t have the skill or know how to correct it.  I may try manipulating the board so that area looks as normal as possible and then pasting it in later.  The whole right side of the map is blurry due to lens distortion from taking the pic relatively close.  Other pics that I have with clarity for that area will be stitched together and should take care of that.  I am keeping the map changes in mind.

When I get that far I will be adding sz 128 to the Caspian sea and I plan on correcting the sz 5/Korea area.  I didn’t know there was a problem with Greenland.  I didn’t see Krieghund say anything about that one.  I guess I could move it some, but that is way down on my list for now.  I had forgotten about the map color differences.  I can take care of that too.

Keep up the input.  I don’t take as an offense to it as it will help me in my finished product.

Thanks,
Dave

Yea, that is something I intend to do. They were all taken at night under less than ideal light.  Instead of changing the contrast and brightness on the individual photos, I’m going to wait until they are all stitched together and do it once.

OK,

After seeing what Nimitz did with a wall mounted map, he really lit a fire underneath me to do it too.  This is not meant to slight his map (which is really good after all), but I wanted the EXACT map on the wall (plus maybe a tweak or two that I like  :-D).  It just looks too beautiful to not be done as good as my abilities allow.  Here is the link, http://www.megaupload.com/?d=JY05IHUK

So, I have had to jump into using Photoshop for the very first time.  Wow, that is a complex program to learn for a newbie!!!  To date, I have the left panel of the Europe map stitched together and corrected.  Things to note:  I expanded the left edge of the map so that I could add new territory and make Manitoba and the Central US connect like they are supposed to.  I also corrected how sz 106 joins up with Quebec, Nova Scotia, and definitely doesn’t join up with the E. US anymore.

I know that some of Europe is a bit fuzzy right now.  That is due to lens distortion from the camera.  It will be corrected as I stitch in more pictures that have clearer shots of that part of the map.  Before doing any photo stitching though, I have to correct the errors in the base photos or else they seem to be amplified when stitched together.  With 21 pics total, this is going to take me a few weeks to complete in most likely.

What I am asking for is other eyes to check out my map as I go along to see if you can catch my mistakes.  Other things for me to point out too:  I haven’t figured out how to correct  all the words that are on the creases.  Some, I can copy from other locations and paste, but many are unique and I’ve done the best with my limited knowledge of Photoshop.  Also, some of the numbers are a tad off color due to copy and pasting from other parts of the map.  Again, I don’t know how to correct that yet.

Other than that, let me know anything on your mind.

Thanks for the inspiration to due this Nimitz,
Dave

edit:  please keep an eye out for how the sea zone lines meet up.  Those seem to take the brunt of mistakes when stitching the pics together.

February 15, 2011

Ok, I’ve been working on this some more and I am coming at it from a different angle.  I have completed the second panel on the Pacific side of the board (the one with W. US).  I don’t like how the Convoy raid markers look on the board.  I changed the one by Hawaii so that it is the same color as the sea zone numbers.  Check it out and see if this is a change that you like.  Other than that, it should be exactly as the board appears, only cleaned up.

Here is the new link, http://www.megaupload.com/?d=JMOJJ7TJ

Thanks for you input,
Dave

February 22

I now have the Pacific map done except for deciding the final color of the ‘convoy’ and ‘kamikaze’ markers.  I have some different colors for the convoy markers that I want feedback on.  In no particular order, they are in sea zones 63, 20, 62, 54, 37, 43, 36, 10, and 26.  I have a couple that I like, but I don’t want to say which because I don’t want to influence anyone else prior to their viewing.

I made two changes: 1.) I corrected the sea zone border with Korea/Amur and 2.) I deleted that 50 ipc marker from the W. US and centered the 10 ipc marker.

Here is the new link,  http://www.megaupload.com/?d=ZMRG6UUD

See what you think and let me know.
Dave

March 7

The map is finished.  My wife reminded me that this is copyrighted material so I have contacted Wizards of the Coast for permission to post it here.  I am awaiting a response from them.  I really hope they allow me to post it.  It would be a great addition to the community if I can.

March 25

Well, I finally heard back from Wizards.  It was a big fat no.  Not even a nice no.  After waiting almost one month, after explaining everything I had done and I wanted to do, it was simply this:

"I am sorry that you have had to wait so long for a reply to your question regarding permission to reprint the game boards from Axis and Allies: Europe 1940 and Pacific 1940, and to print and post the map.

Unfortunately, I cannot provide you with that permission.  Wizards does not grant permission for these types of use of the Axis and Allies property.

Best regards,
Hilary

Hilary Ross
Associate Brand Manager
Wizards of the Coast"

Boy, nice to know they are watching out for us and they like to interact with their fan base. :-P :-P :-P

So, no one is getting this map from me.  Not with a definitive no from Wizards at least.  Sorry for getting everyone’s hopes up.

What does the “TD” stand for in the dashed box?

Nimitz,

You have two sea zones numbered 33.  I think the one by FIC is supposed to be sz 36.

Nimitz,

I noticed a misspelling on the Pacific side:  Paulau Island in sz 34.  You have it as “Pelau”

Also, if you don’t mind my asking, some of the islands in the Pacific are distorted compared to the regular board (Philippines, Carolines, Gilbert, Paulau come to mine.  Actually, Gilbert doesn’t even have a visible island, just the UK roundel).  Was this something you had to do in your ‘paint’ program to clean up the picture? I do not mean to offend, so please don’t take it that way.  I only ask because of curiosity.

Nimitz,

What type of metal did you mount it to?  Was it stainless steel?  If it wasn’t, I am wondering if you have had any corrosion problems beneath the vinyl.

Sweet.  This is a project I am totally doing.

What adhesive are you using for the magnets?  It looks like hot glue or epoxy from the photos.

Nimitz,

How do you use chips on the wall?  Does each chip get its own magnet? Do you just paint some magnets to represent chips?  How thick are these magnets and where would you get them?  How does the map not get torn up over time with moving the magnets over paper?

This idea really, really intrigues me.  Do you have any pics of an existing game you have that employs this?  If so, could you post some pictures please?

Dave