Posts made by Gorshak

@666

Small but decisive victory for the Italians - The med has been cleared of enemy vessels.

italy-10-finish.tsvg

@666

sorry for the long delay - next 2 moves will be much quicker though. Oh, and please ignore the 3 rolls on the dice server - that was by mistake (and also no hit was rolled for anyone in any case).

American fighter can scramble into the med.

italy-10-combat.tsvg

@666
Yes, even though Europe looks very bad for the Axis, the overall game is still exciting. I am curious what you will do.

@666
now worries - I hope it was the enjoyable life and not the troublesome one

@666

japan-10-finish.tsvg

@666

germany-10-finish.tsvg

@666

scramble options for the carrier.

germany-10-combat.tsvg

@666

I am very sorry for the loong delay - it will not happen again.

italy-9-finish.tsvg

I have a question regarding the rules of non-combat-move (NCM) of the German transports in sz116 - with a russian Sub in the same seazone:

Is there any legal way in the rules for the fleet to stay in the same field, sink the sub, and NCM transport ground troops from a friendly territory to another friendly territory (for example from Germany to Norway)?

As i understand the rules, I could load troops, attack the sub and amphibious assault for example Denmark (if Denmark would be Allied occupied).

From the point of realism it should therefore also be possible to do NCM in the same seazone (if you can do an assault against enemy territory it should also be possible to unload in a friendly port).

But if i look at the rules in detail it seems i can either load troops in combat-move and do an amphibious assault (same seazone or different one) - or i do not move in combat-move with the transports. But in both ways they cannot move in NCM anymore (assuming that i attack the sub).

So it somehow looks to me that the only legal way in the rules to be able to do a NCM with the 2 trans is not to attack the sub?

Is this correct or do I miss something?

@666

I have a question regarding the understanding of the rules:
It is about the German fleet in the Baltic with the Russian Sub.

Do you know if there is any legal way in the rules for the fleet to stay in the same field, sink the sub, and NCM transport ground troops from a friendly territory to another friendly territory?

For sure I could load troops, attack the sub and amphibious assault Denmark for example (if Denmark would be Allied occupied) - or move the transports and amphibious assault the Baltic States.

From the point of realism it should therefore be possible to also do NCM in the same seazone (if you can do an assault against enemey territory it should also be possible to unload in a friendly port).

For sure it is possible if i do not attack the sub and just ignore it.

But if i look at the rules in detail it seems i can either load troops in combat-move and do an amphibious assault (same seazone or different one) - or i do not move in combat-move with the trans, but then they cannot move anymore in NCM (assuming that i attack the sub).

So it somehow looks to me that the only way to be able to do a NCM with the 2 trans is not to attack the sub?

@666

brilliant moves in the Pacific!

I will probably be mostly offline until the weekend - so it might take a few days until i can find a proper repsonse on the battlefield.

@666

no scramble

@666
no stress :)

@666

lol

japan-9-finish.tsvg

@666

japan-9-combat.tsvg

scramble options in the 2 naval battles and in Burma

@666

germany-9-finish.tsvg

@tizkit

very good explanation of the variables and considerations!
:)

@666

italy-8-finish.tsvg

@666

Again 44 IPC worse battle results than the expected results :see_no_evil:

japan-8-finish.tsvg

@666

Yes, in the video AH is urged to finally face reality and capitulate - but he is continuously rejecting to do so. To not give Churchill the satisfaction and also because he believes that he might even still win the war in the end.

Regarding Germany’s turn in the game - I believe the German Navy and Airforce are just not made for naval battles. Let’s see what the Allied Navy will do.

germany-8-finish.tsvg