Posts made by dutchmand

With the bye in the tourny, I am available for another league game. PM me.

Question about Panama… the territory.

Does Panama really touch E US? That seems silly.  Panama (or even the Central American countries it represents) are thousands of miles from the US border, through Mexico. To get to the Panama, you should have to go through CUS, Mexico and then to Panama. Or at least through Mexico.

Is it really just 1 move from Washington DC to Panama… over land?

OK, I may have founf the answer.  The aa gun converts ownership to the new owner of the territory, whoever that is.  So, because the British will own the territory, they will own the aa gun.

So, in theory, the chinese could own an aa gun with Russian help.  If the Russians captured a Japanese aa gun in Manchuria, the aa gun would go over to the Chinese as owners of the liberated territory.

Also, you might have a strange scenerio where the India aa gun is taken to the Phillippenes by the Japanese after it is captured.  Then the Phillipenes is liberated by the Soviets (I know its very unlikley). So, a British aa gun, on US territory, liberated by the Soviets…. it would be a US aa gun as they are the new owners of the freshly liberated territory.

Can you confirm that this is correct Krieghund?

Krieghund,

OK, I gues I need a little more help on the aa gun thing.  OK, so Japan captures Indias aa gun. Japan moves it to Persia. Soviets liberate it there.  Is the aa gun British or Soviet?

So, if Apollo is a no show, then we still need one more for 40.

1.  DarthMaximus
2.  DutchmanD
3.  DY
4.  DesertJournalist
5.  Zygmund
6.  Telamon
7.  Bigbadgoo
8.  SgtBlitz
9.  Pin
10. Questioneer
11. TimTheEnchanter
12. Omega
13. Bardoly
14. Gargantua
15. Lynxes
16. Perrys!
17. Joe Cold
18. KGB
19. Todd7912
20. HannibalSW
21. katfishkris
22. souL
23. Apollo
24. DemolitionMan
25. a44bigdog
26. Mistergreen
27. P@nther
28. Botider
29. JWW
30. PGMatt
31. hobo
32. Yasha
33. Cmdr Jennifer
34. bongaroo
35. anchovy
36. mojo
37. Emperor Mollari
38. BigRedOne
39. Ryx
40. Canuck12

OK, everybody. The proper way to sign up is to copy and paste the list from the previous post and put it into your reply, adding your name and number.

Like this:

1.  DarthMaximus
2.  DutchmanD
3.  DY
4.  DesertJournalist
5.  Zygmund
6.  Telamon
7.  Bigbadgoo
8.  SgtBlitz
9.  Pin
10. Questioneer
11. TimTheEnchanter
12. Omega
13. Bardoly
14. Gargantua
15. Lynxes
16. Perrys!
17. Joe Cold
18. KGB
19. Todd7912
20. HannibalSW
21. katfishkris
22. souL
23. Apollo
24. DemolitionMan
25. a44bigdog
26. Mistergreen
27. P@nther
28. Botider
29. JWW
30. PGMatt
31. hobo
32. Yasha
33. Cmdr Jennifer
34. bongaroo
35. anchovy
36. mojo
37. Emperor Mollari
38. BigRedOne

NM

I see you posted the answer on March 30. The aa gun would belong to the Soviets.

Kreighund,

AA guns
The rules say that an aa gun captured by the enemy that is later liberated by a nation friendly with the original owning country returns to the possession of the original country who owned it.  Is this always the case?

For example, the Japs cature the aa gun in India. Over the course of the next few turns they move it to Caucasus.  The Russians then liberate Caucasus. Is the AA gun now Russian or is it British?

• I meant to say

“I don’t think anyone who did well in the previous tourny should ‘cry’ about not getting a bye”

:cry:

OK, so its 36 for now. Anyone interested, please sign-up. We’ll figure out how to do the byes one way or another.  I’ll take a bye if one comes my way, but I don’t think anyone who did well in the previous tourny should about not getting a bye. Good players don’t need no stinking byes! (just good dice rolls  8-) )

Darth, make sure to gimme Tim the Enchanter on the draw. You owe me a rematch Tim!  :-P

1.  DarthMaximus
2.  DutchmanD
3.  DY
4.  DesertJournalist
5.  Zygmund
6.  Telamon
7.  Bigbadgoo
8.  SgtBlitz
9.  Pin
10. Questioneer
11. TimTheEnchanter
12. Omega
13. Bardoly
14. Gargantua
15. Lynxes
16. Perrys!
17. Joe Cold
18. KGB
19. Todd7912
20. HannibalSW
21. katfishkris
22. souL
23. Apollo
24. DemolitionMan
25. a44bigdog
26. Mistergreen
27. P@nther
28. Botider
29. JWW
30. PGMatt
31. hobo
32. Yasha
33. Cmdr Jennifer
34. bongaroo
35. anchovy
36. mojo

I’m in

1.  DarthMaximus
2.  DutchmanD
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.

If one comes on here and makes a bold statement about how something should be done and does so in somewhat of an arrogant manner, then I would suggest that that person has assumed an implied duty to verify their statement; especially if such proof is as easy as writting a letter.  Maybe Bardoly did not have a “burden of proof” before he decided to condescend to IL, but that changed when he decided to get on his soap box and to make the post that he did.

I’ve got an idea.

Bardoly, you write a letter, the most professional, beautifully composed letter you have ever written, using all your years of retail experience to muster up the perfect letter, and then return and report how WOTC responds to your prose.

If the months go by, and they don’t respond, or they respond with some type of company form letter that says how grateful they are for your comments, but nothing changes, you’ll be good enough to tell us about it.

If they do change their ways and by some miracle start selling the pieces, all hats are off to you and many people will return to post on this board to thank you for you great work and insight.

My money is on nothing changing, but I’d be more than happy to be proved wrong.

I am looking for some players for an AA 50 game.  I am not set on any nation or side I want to be, just want to get some more practice in, but I would like more than just a 1v1 if we could in order to get that multiplayer dynamic.  Probably 41 scenario, National Objectives for sure, but techs can be voted on.

OK, we got a full game. Thanks guys

Thanks. Makes perfect sense.  Going to have to kill me some fighters. :-)

Sorry if this has already been answered, but I did go through about 12 pages on this board a few weeks ago so I have done some homework.

I just couldnt remember this one:

Germany attacks z6 with subs, UK has a CV and some fighters. However, Germany is also bringing loaded transports.  The subs sink the CV, planes still remain. Now that the subs and planes cannot hit each other, does the attack have to withdraw the tranports to avoid being autokilled, or do the fighters have to withdraw and Germany takes the sea zone and can then land the loaded ground units?

What is the answer here?

OK, we got 4 so far. Italy is taken. Need 2 more. Message me if interested.

Looking to start a new 6 player game. AA 50 '41 with NOs. Tech is optional (we can vote on it). My brother wants to play, so I have one already. PM me and/or post if you want in.

OK, d142 joined as Soviet Union. Need just 1 UK player.