@Plekto:
…What you need to do is rob Germany of Africa and place the IC at a spot that can’t easily be taken out.
The optimal place to put the IC is actually Egypt…
But you will need U.S. support, so you might have to wait until turn 2 to place it unless the German med fleet is badly beaten…
Russia can also of course send air cover for it if you decide to build it on turn 1.
Do I understand correctly that you’re proposing reclaiming Africa from Germany, beating up the German Med fleet, and putting an IC in Anglo-Egypt by turn 2? And that you’re proposing sending a Russian fighter to Anglo-Egypt on R1? (Giving Germany slightly better odds on a two-territory R1 attack?)
Response: I pick up infantry and tank from Southern Europe, plus Libya infantry and tank, plus bomber, and probably 2 fighters. This, versus infantry, tank, and two fighters. My battleship must win versus your destroyer, but those are good odds. You never get the Anglo-Egypt IC up, and I kill a precious Russian fighter, while keepipng most of or all of my air, probably leaving a tank ready to blitz through Africa. Russian fighters are like gold in my opinion; they allow Russia to trade territories without committing ground forces to hold the territory (since the Germans usually take the territory right back, destroying any Russian forces there.)
Sure, this means the UK battleship and transports may survive, but Russian fighters are SOLID GOLD IMHO.
Alternative, I only have 1 fighter, and you overcommitted in Ukraine. I still attack Anglo-Egypt, with slightly worse odds, but am compensated by obliterating Russian tanks in Ukraine. This is an even better scenario for Germany.
Last alternative, you undercommitted to a Ukraine attack, lucked out, and won big. Which just goes to show that in war, it’s better to be lucky than smart/valorous/other adjective.
I’m still curious as to how you intend to beat up the German Med fleet. If Anglo-Egypt holds, yes, I can see the Indian fleet and the Anglo-Egypt fighter making a good case against the German Med fleet. I just don’t think Anglo-Egypt should ever last past G1, though.