@General_D.Fox:
@ncscswitch:
Well, we ahve an upcoming game, so I guess we can put this to rest in the near future :-)
I declare the front row seat for this game! Two big kahunas who can talk the talk AND walk the walk. And soon, apparently, one’s laurels and convictions will be put to the test! Viva la A&A!!!
I don’t think the game will prove or disprove a KJF effective. Four reasons.
1. Luck will play a factor, and a bit of luck in a naval battle type game can be very decisive.
2. If the KJF succeeds or fails, there is no way to measure the relative merits of KJF to KGF. (If the KJF fails, you could say the KGF would have failed as well; if the KJF succeeds, you could say the KGF would have succeeded as well).
3. I think both players will depart from the optimal line, so the optimal line of play will not be explored. This will happen from chance if not from suboptimal builds, combat choices, and movement.
4. An opening at Germany can see the game switch to KGF before the crucial UK turn, or even before the deciding US turn.