@cwglee51 Hey what version of tripleA is this?
PtV Nikola1975 (axis+6) vs Max334
-
@max334 maybe not great odds…but good odds…I guess thats 75%
-
@max334 Hm, you are right. Ok if I change 1 sub for 1 destroyer? And in that case, what will you do with fighters?
-
@max334 No, it is not right after all. Planes can hit subs if there is a destroyer there. So, I am staying with 2 subs as originally intended :)
Let me know if you are scrambling -
@nikola1975 t I’m looking on page 33 of the rule book and it says the DD has to be from your side (ie ‘destroyer friendly to the air units in the battle’).
-
@nikola1975 Let me know what you want to send and I’ll decide on the scramble
-
@max334 2 subs. I tried to run the move offline, it killed the subs from the fighters. If you have a destroyer in the battle, you are able to hit the subs and the other side can chose them as casualties.
-
@nikola1975 its a player enforced rule
-
@max334 makes sense… planes cant hit subs
-
do we hold for a decision from like a moderator or experienced player?
-
@max334 No, you are wrong:
https://axisallies.com/global-1940-second-edition-rules/
You can ask someone if you wish.
-
Yes destroyers do change the situation but the destroyer has to be friendly to the air unit attacking.
-
@max334 if you had to destroyer it would change the situation but you can’t use my destroyer to your advantage
-
@max334 Well, what I understand here is that air units require destroyer which is friendly to them. Your air units to have a destroyer that is friendly unit. Isn’t this saying so?
If you can find someone to ask, it would help, this is interesting case to know for the future.
-
ok, I’ll ask simon33
-
@nikola1975 You have to bring a dd ( from your side ) to be able to hit enemy subs from your planes; even if Max has a dd. If your planes hit X2 and Max has only one dd, only the dd can be chosen for the casualty. You cannot use his dd for his advantage, Max should have the option to even submerge the subs because you are not bringing a dd.
-
@sovietishcat thank you for helping with that
-
if my DD hits you can assign to your sub, but not hits from my planes unless you bring in your own DD
-
Can’t Be Hit by Air Units: When attacking or defending, hits scored by air units can’t be assigned to submarines unless
there is a destroyer that is friendly to the air units in the battle Page 33 from Europe rule book. Allies dd are not friendly to axis. hope it helps. -
ok Nikola… no scrambles … and I better not see you doing a victory dance
-
@max334 hm, cant upload the game, it seems there is some problem with a forum. will try later
Suggested Topics
