League General Discussion Thread

No doubt about it, russia is neutral on pac map if not at war with japan and all neutral rules apply.

@majikforce said in League General Discussion Thread:

Need rules help. I’m too lazy and busy to look through the rule book but I know you can’t land US bombers in Amur that are attacking Korea if Russia is neutral with Japan. And please correct me if I am wrong on that.

The US bombers cannot land there unless Japan is at War with Russia as otherwise Russia is neutral instead of being friendly.

Air Units: An air unit must end its move in an eligible landing space. Air units can land in any territory that was friendly (but
not friendly neutral) at the start of the current turn.

@AndrewAAGamer @Avner @ksmckay Thanks guys!

Hi all, looking for a game of BM3.

IMPORTANT note to all:

DO NOT go to TripleA 2.2.x or later, as there is a very nasty battle calc bug that hangs every time you try to do a naval battle calc involving offensive subs. It has made my game with ksmckay miserable, to the point where we decided to recreate our game (only into round 3) using TripleA 1.9. And you can’t correct the problem using a later TripleA client version, as the bug exists in the game save itself. Here’s our game for your further reference: https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/35823/axis-dominion-vs-ksmckay-allies-18-bm3/109

I did NOT experience this issue in version 2.1.20625, FYI, so I believe that is a safer 2.1.x version. I can’t say for sure if this started only as of 2.2.x and if so, which specific ‘x’ that is, but it’s nasty nasty nasty, I promise you will hate your life, so avoid like the plague!!!

Subs seem to be having problems all round at the moment…I had a game where all their stealth capabilities were turned off…very annoying!

Yah sadly a lot of quality issues with 2.x release. I’m just going to stick with 1.9 for a while longer, until these problems clear up.

I have moved the follow up discussion about issues with TripleA to the TripleA Support Category , as this is a general TripleA-related issue and not a “League-issue”:

https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/35846/submarine-related-issues-with-triplea/

Please discuss TripleA issues in this forum-category. They will likely get noticed and addressed earlier. Also you can get quicker information about new or known issues, latest versions etc., there.

@Panther

Can allies move thought a friendly neutral the same turn it is activated? Like, 1 man moves in to activate friendly neutral but tanks by same player in friendly neighboring territory then can move through to another friendly terr.?

@Karl7 No, see https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/post/1439525

@axis-dominion said in League General Discussion Thread:

IMPORTANT note to all:

DO NOT go to TripleA 2.2.x or later, as there is a very nasty battle calc bug that hangs every time you try to do a naval battle calc involving offensive subs. It has made my game with ksmckay miserable, to the point where we decided to recreate our game (only into round 3) using TripleA 1.9. And you can’t correct the problem using a later TripleA client version, as the bug exists in the game save itself. Here’s our game for your further reference: https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/35823/axis-dominion-vs-ksmckay-allies-18-bm3/109

I did NOT experience this issue in version 2.1.20625, FYI, so I believe that is a safer 2.1.x version. I can’t say for sure if this started only as of 2.2.x and if so, which specific ‘x’ that is, but it’s nasty nasty nasty, I promise you will hate your life, so avoid like the plague!!!

unfortunately I had not read and I had the same problem in the game with dawegoneit…

I wish they would fix the bug where playing on local loses all of the forum play information.

Does anybody else use this for battle calc?

https://aacalc.freezingblue.com/?page=calc

@LennardF Yeah, but it doesn’t include P2V rules.

@Avner said in League General Discussion Thread:

unfortunately I had not read and I had the same problem in the game with dawegoneit…

Did you notice the suggestion that this only happens if you load it up with an earlier version? If you use 2.2.20868, there is no evidence there is a problem (yet).

Essentially, all players should use the same version and then the problem doesn’t occur. I’m playing two games at the moment, one using 2.2.20868 and for the other I’m using 2.1.20365 because that’s what my opponent is using.

And it’s more than just the game hanging, it also removes sub evasion and submerging, and it interferes with the subs stealth movement.

@simon33 said in League General Discussion Thread:

@LennardF Yeah, but it doesn’t include P2V rules.

@Avner said in League General Discussion Thread:

unfortunately I had not read and I had the same problem in the game with dawegoneit…

Did you notice the suggestion that this only happens if you load it up with an earlier version? If you use 2.2.20868, there is no evidence there is a problem (yet).

yes… this version :( … but …perhaspboth players must have it?

Not only must both players use it, they must use it every time. A single save with an earlier version will cause the problem.

A ghost sighting!!!

TripleA is telling me there’s a new version available - I’m gonna hold off until I finish current games but I’m curious if anybody has tried out the new version.

“A new version of TripleA is out. Please Update TripleA!
Your current version: 2.2.20868 Latest version available for download: 2.3.22161”

I use 2.4.22179. Works fine.

Watch out when using battle calc in version 2.5 (maybe even in some previous versions)

In previous version u had to turn on the ADD AMPHIBIOUS ATTACK MODIFIERS

for your bats and cruisers shots to be included in the calculation.

Now U dont, u just put the cruisers and bats in the calculator, and even u havent pressed ADD AMPHIBIOUS ATTACK MODIFIERS

it still counts as if u had.

it will give u the same results, either u pressed or not have pressed the ADD AMPHIBIOUS ATTACK MODIFIERS button