The Germans have no destroyer present, therefore the defending air units can not hit the sub, and of course the sub can never hit planes. Think of it in terms of the combined arms rule, air units can only hit subs if they are combined with at least 1 participating destroyer, the difference with this particular combined arms is that it works while attacking and defending. In the scenario that you described, the sub would destroy the remaining transport without rolling and the defending fighters can do nothing.
Question about surprise attacks on carriers
-
would planes still be considered cargo during a initial surprise attack from subs if the carrier is alone? (No destroyer or any other units in the zone)
We’ve gone over the rules for damaged carriers, surprise attacks, combat sequence and the rules seem vague at best.Given the nature of a surprise sub attack I find it unlikely that planes would already be in the air ready to defend before they ever knew an attack was coming.
regardless were just looking for a fair ruling we can apply unilaterally.Thanks in advance for any help! :-D
-
would planes still be considered cargo during a initial surprise attack from subs if the carrier is alone? (No destroyer or any other units in the zone)
We’ve gone over the rules for damaged carriers, surprise attacks, combat sequence and the rules seem vague at best.Here is the rule:
@rulebook:
Air Defense: Whenever an undamaged carrier is attacked, its aircraft (even those belonging to friendly powers) are considered
to be defending in the air and fight normally, even if only submarines are attacking and the air units cannot hit them because
there is no defending destroyer.
…
When a damaged carrier is attacked, any air units on board are considered cargo and can’t defend.Planes of a nation friendly to an attacking carrier are also considered as cargo.
HTH :-)
-
Thanks we have the old rule book, that’s much clearer
Suggested Topics
