Thats crazy…… :mrgreen:
The idea is that they’re firing at the units coming ashore, who are in no position to return fire, certainly not from artillery.
Yea, I like the rule. But they fire twice?
That seems odd.
In our game they fire twice, due to having the convergence of two forts in that sea zone.
I’m a bit confused by this excerpt:
“If you move all of your units out of a contested territory and leave only units from the other side there, the other side will
immediately claim the territory (see “Taking Control of a Territory”, page 20). If the territory was originally controlled by a
power on the other side, that power will take control (even if it has no units present).”
Do you have to leave an occupational force in captured enemy territory?
I think that means if you leave a contested territory. If they attacked you, lost all their units, the territory stays theirs until your turn.
You can’t leave, or it reverts back to their control.
Imagine if Russia is trying to flush the Turks out of Romania (Russian controlled)
They attack 10 Inf with 4 inf and 4 Artillery, but the defending turks score 8 hits.
Because the territory can’t become turkish on the Russian turn, when the Turkish turn comes around, this rule informs you that at least one unit of yours must stay in Romania, though it is empty of enemy forces, to establish control. Your entire force can’t charge onward to the Ukraine because only during YOUR turn can you take control of a territory.
So the territory remains contested until Ottomans turn?
Another question, can Austria-Hungary or Turkey declare unrestricted submarine warfare and if so does that force a US entry as well? The rule book specifies Germany. Are Austro-Hungarian
and Ottoman subs considered so subpar that they can’t declare USW?
@Hitlers:
I’m a bit confused by this excerpt:
“If you move all of your units out of a contested territory and leave only units from the other side there, the other side will immediately claim the territory (see Taking Control of a Territory, page 20). If the territory was originally controlled by a power on the other side, that power will take control (even if it has no units present).”
Do you have to leave an occupational force in captured enemy territory?
No. The rule says “and leave only units from the other side there”. If the territory has been captured, there will be no units from the other side in it.
I think that means if you leave a contested territory.
Correct.
If they attacked you, lost all their units, the territory stays theirs until your turn.
You can’t leave, or it reverts back to their control.
No. If all of the units from one side are removed from the territory for any reason, it is no longer contested and will become controlled immediately.
I am not going back and answering any questions in this thread from before the Rulebook was posted.
It remains contested even if the enemy killed themselves attacking you. But only in the case where they are trying to push you out of a territory they control.
If they fail to do so, it doesn’t become yours until your turn.
This rule will only matter in counterattacks that get eliminated.
If you simply pull out of a contested territory it does become theirs though.
Poor Kreig… :-o
It’s like having a baby and now you can’t do anything anymore…
@Hitlers:
Another question, can Austria-Hungary or Turkey declare unrestricted submarine warfare and if so does that force a US entry as well?
No.
It remains contested even if the enemy killed themselves attacking you. But only in the case where they are trying to push you out of a territory they control.
If they fail to do so, it doesn’t become yours until your turn.
Wrong.
Ok….now we are getting somewhere.
Can you repair at a friendly port?
Are US land units allowed on allied soil, before the US is at war officially, if so what is the rationale behind that?
If the Ottoman Empire controls Constatinople, but has no naval units in sea zone 20, can a British battleship move freely from sea zone 19 to sea zone 20, where it rolls for mines due to the Ottoman naval base, and then continue on to sea zone 21?
The Russian Revolution optional rule is being used. Early in the game Russia had taken control of a neutral Holland upon a German attack and a few turns later was able, with British help, to drive the Germans out of Holland. Russian troops remain in Holland, which is controlled by Russia.
The next turn, the Russian Revolution occurs. Since Holland is Russian controlled, Russian troops remain in Holland, per the Russian Revolution Rules (“All Russian units outside of original Russian territories or Russian-controlled territories are immediately removed from the board, and Russia will no longer have a turn”).
Does this mean that Germany and the other Central Powers may no longer attack Holland?
May Allied powers still move freely through Holland?
The idea is that they’re firing at the units coming ashore, who are in no position to return fire, certainly not from artillery.
This should be used in A&A 1940 Europe & Pacific also
I suggested that to Larry a million times
People had boners for blockhouses when the game came out bit I said artillery sould sub in as coastal guns and roll preemptively. Larry said it was an ok idea, i guess he came around.
You don’t even need Russian units present; even if all the Russio-Dutch are eliminated, as far as I can tell Russia remains the nominated Allied controlling power of Holland for the rest of the game. Again, the rules could be interpreted differently…
The Russian Revolution optional rule is being used. Early in the game Russia had taken control of a neutral Holland upon a German attack and a few turns later was able, with British help, to drive the Germans out of Holland. Russian troops remain in Holland, which is controlled by Russia.
The next turn, the Russian Revolution occurs. Since Holland is Russian controlled, Russian troops remain in Holland, per the Russian Revolution Rules (“All Russian units outside of original Russian territories or Russian-controlled territories are immediately removed from the board, and Russia will no longer have a turn”).
Does this mean that Germany and the other Central Powers may no longer attack Holland?
May Allied powers still move freely through Holland?
Can you confirm:
I cannot repair BBs at friendly NBs, but I may do so at a captured enemy NB I control.
Once a particular power has been nominated to control a non-aligned neutral, or an enemy aligned neutral, it remains the nominated nation in that tt for that side for the rest of the game, even if the tt is lost and subsequently recaptured by one of my allies.
Britain and France are defending in a contested tt. They have 1 infantry each remaining, and take one last hit. If they cannot agree as to who removes the last casualty, the attacking player decides.
Question: can I purchase naval units if the enemy controls all my original home NBs? That is, I buy them in anticipation of recapturing a NB on this turn.
If yes, then I presume that any units so purchased are lost if I fail to recapture the base.
