@frimmel:
I can’t argue that other than “Sith” the prequels are “good” movies but they are by no means travesties of cinema. They each have some pretty neat stuff in them despite maybe not overall “working.” I think at this point the pile on is just habit and not wanting to seem “uncool.” Like you’d be one of “those” fans instead of one of the cool nerds.
Yes, I really don’t have the vehement issues with the prequels that many do; partially because I was younger when they came out and generally enjoyed them. I do, however, recognize their faults and the disconnection of tone from Ep IV-V-VI. They are not all they could have been, but are not, as you said, travesties of cinema.
@frimmel:
The example I use is “Temple of Doom.” It has some problems but the chief problem is it isn’t “Raiders of the Lost Ark” and this causes its problems to be unfairly magnified.
Yes, I agree. Watching it again recently I could tell how poor of a movie it was in comparison to Raiders. It isn’t that it was a particularly bad movie; Temple has some excellent scenes, and it might very well have been my favorite when I was growing up. For some reason though, there just isn’t the same impact found in Raiders or even Last Crusade… which is also not as good as Raiders.
The comparisons will always be there, but that is both good and bad.
@frimmel:
JJ stole one of the worst sequences from the Star Wars prequels for Trek (09) but I keep coming across those who vehemently hate the prequels but love the lens flared mess of JJ Trek.
Which scene are you referencing?
@frimmel:
Everyone will be so excited to see Han shoot first (mark it down, at some point Han will shoot before the other guy gets a chance) they’ll be willing to overlook the other mediocrity he’ll shovel at us.
That is the sad part about commercialized franchises which thrive on the memory of the past. Put in enough tributes, easter eggs or character throwbacks and it will appease the masses. Discerning minds who want something new, innovative, respectful and true to the original will see through the bones thrown, but for the rest it will be a laugh and a feel good romp down memory lane and they’ll just throw money at it.