You are right. I agree with you. We should follow the rules of this tournament. Gargantua says: Either players choose to agree to a bid, or the Arbitrary coin falls! It means for me that when one side wants a coin then, if opponents pick up the coin too – coin falls and everybody is happy. If the opponents want a bid, which is our case, there is a disagreement and coin falls again. Sands like as long as one side likes a coin, the other side opinion is irrelevant. So, the rules force our decision, not me. If you have another rule interpretation, we need Garg’s help. I am ok with waiting for Stirling.