My roll should be counted in every round because the correct number of dice was rolled for me each round. I am saying that if too many dice are rolled for a certain unit type, the roll should not be “rerolled” but instead the extra number of dice should just be removed from the roll, or something similar. Here, you rolled too many threes in round 2 and round 3. There should have been 2 for each round but you rolled 3 for each round. In this case, should the third dice not just be removed since it should not have been rolled?
So, in rounds 2 and 3, the first two threes rolled missed both times. A similar process would be done if you had rolled one too few of the fighters. If you had rolled only one when there were supposed to be 2, you would just roll an extra dice for the second fighter, not reroll for both fighters.
I do not like the idea of rerolls. Clearly 2 of your 3 fighters missed in the third round. If you reroll, then your fighters hit 2/2. I do not think that is the way to do it.
To show my point I will use an exaggeration that should make it clear. If I had 30 tanks and I mistakenly rolled 31 dice and I hit you 3 times, would you be ok with me “rerolling” 30 dice? I would think it is clear that one of the 31 should be removed not all dice rerolled. If a person were willing to accept a reroll, then they should never be able to be hit more times than 3. Here you went from hitting once to hitting twice. Just because there was only one hit needed, it does not matter. You went from hitting one in three (33%) to hitting 2/2 (100%).
Do you see what I am saying? Since only one hit could be made anyway, the most I would be willing to accept is to give you a 33% chance of hitting in the third round. So if you want to roll 1@2 and you hit, I will give you credit for a hit in the third round with a fighter. I hope you are able to understand my point, I am not trying to be a stickler about this, but I have to say what I think is right.
Cheers
Rolling 1:
