Submarines

@LewisClark You’re welcome. Enjoy the game!

@ampdrive

Thank you for clarifying!

The follow up conversation has been moved here:

https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/36451/submarine-movement-and-customized-map

G40 :anguished:

I believe they made Submarines weak for defense to 1 because every single player would pump out cheap Sub. to boost their navy so this allowed great strength for destroyer + “any” attacks to have the advantage.

@Fatespinner:

But what about unloading into a friendly land during non-combat. Can the sub there also be just ignored? I think the OP question is concerned about this and not amphibious assault.

See Private Panic’s answer above.

Thanks Krieghund, you explain it much better :)

Well, I really don’t like the wording of it in the rule-book, it’s not as unambiguous as I like, but again, computer programmers are an anal bunch.  I am surprised the voting was as one sided as it was but I can see it either way, that’s the problem for me.  The rules should not have to be submitted to an linguistics expert, it would be great to see an explicit mention of a partial sub fleet submergence while the rest carry on first shot attacking or defending.  I will sleep at night just fine until that ever occurs however!