Well… I’m not saying this to be contentious, but they are gray. A very deep gray, seriously. Even when you look at modeling paints which say “German Gray” the paint is nearly black - nearly. Though truth be told, from what I’ve seen (in life and in books/ on websites) they used many shades of gray - just so happens that this time WOTC picked the darker shade. That being said, my personal opinion is that it should be the lighter gray of previous editions… not that it matters since I paint 'em anyway. For example my Panzers are German Gray - and it isn’t a whole lot of difference between the final shade of paint and the mini’s original colour.