@ABWorsham:
You own a NFL team. The team is down by 5 points with 90 yards between you and a championship. There is two minutes on the clock.
If you could have any NFL QB past or present who do you pick?
As much as it pains me to say it, Joe Montana.
@General:
I’d go with an in-his-prime Elway, his scrambling ability would be important. Second choice would be Montana.
For current players I’d go with Rodgers for the same reason. Great arm and escapability.
Can’t really argue against Elway. Or any QB on this list: http://espn.go.com/nfl/superbowl/history/mvps
But if we go with guys showing up more than once, Montana is the clear choice with Starr, Bradshaw, and Brady following closest behind. The only guys I think you could consider who don’t show up on this list would be Unitas, Tarkenton, Marino.