13L G40 Boldfresh (+9) vs. Hobo - game 3


  • no, that’s not me and after several discussions about probability you should know that’s not me. I don’t let luck be a factor when I can control it. after that horrible first round why the hell would I give you any more of an advantage of winning since if you redid the probability it was at best a toss up on my part.

    you already rolled round 2 with my fighters.  if you kept the carrier then for round 3 we’ll have to roll here.

  • 12

    ok, i will roll the rest of the battle here after rolling the acc’s through tripleA.

  • 12

    so, you have lost 2 ftrs so far - which 2 ftrs have you lost?


  • lose germans first

  • 12

    alright your acc’s missed.  so here is what we are left with.

    attacker:  sub, 4 ftr, 5 bom
    defender: 8 fighters (6 italian, 2 german)

    since i have a sub and you have no boats, i don’t remember off hand if your transports die automatically or if they only die one at a time if my sub hits.

    to be safe, i will just roll for the sub as well.

    round 3

    attacker:

    sub
    DiceRolls: 1@2; Total Hits: 01@2: (5)

    4 ftr
    DiceRolls: 4@3; Total Hits: 14@3: (4, 6, 1, 6)

    5 bom
    DiceRolls: 5@4; Total Hits: 45@4: (6, 4, 2, 2, 1)

    defender:

    8 ftr
    DiceRolls: 8@4; Total Hits: 58@4: (5, 2, 4, 1, 6, 4, 5, 1)

  • 12

    ok now we are left with:

    attacker

    sub
    DiceRolls: 1@2; Total Hits: 01@2: (5)

    4 bombers
    DiceRolls: 4@4; Total Hits: 44@4: (1, 4, 4, 2)

    defender

    3 italian ftrs
    DiceRolls: 3@4; Total Hits: 33@4: (2, 3, 4)

  • 12

    ok the sub now kills your trannies and i win the battle with 1 bomber - you agree with all that?

  • 12

    i’m going to roll through using tripleA to finish up the battle and will
    edit to match the forum rolls.  disregard the dice.


  • not unusual you win 10-20% battles against me, how many is this already

    no wonder you pushed that russian battle into utterly useless rounds

  • 12

    well be glad we finished it on the forum and not in marti - i saved an extra 3 bombers in the tripleA battle (may have been only 2 if the acc rolled a 3 or 4).  :roll:

  • 12

    nope the acc rolled a “6”.  so you actually got lucky there that we finished it on the forum.
    sucks cuz i need all the help i can get.

  • 12

    ok, we have an issue… amazingly.

    by accident, i took the 2 transports into the battle.  go any issue with saying those were not moved in the combat move but instead just sat still in z125?

  • 12

    this is where “Me1945” would probably INSIST that the transports WERE moved in combat and therefore MUST remain in z110.  :roll: :roll:

  • 12

    @hobo:

    not unusual you win 10-20% battles against me, how many is this already

    no wonder you pushed that russian battle into utterly useless rounds

    dude, i don’t know how to tell you this, but that russian attack…  forget it, it’s just not going to get through to you.  i’m done trying.

    i think you and Me1945 should play, you would be a great match for each other.  :lol:

    but seriously, you should check out what he is asserting in our game, pretty comical.

    i’m almost certain you will not have an issue with me accidentally taking the transports in with the rest of the fleet (shift + click) when there was ZERO reason to take them in.  however, i guess i had better ask.


  • yes once you cleared my air and had any units left my transports are dead. didn’t need that sub since you had a bomber left anyways

    and yes you can relocate your transports

  • 12

    thanks i appreciate your reasonableness in this matter.

    regarding my sub question, what i was getting at is this:  my sub kept firing and you had no boats to defend.  if i had retreated after round 3 where my sub fired and missed, would your transports have survived?  i think the answer is yes.  so since i had the sub, if my air had gotten defeated i would have sunk your trannies of course.  but what i was getting at is would i still have killed your trannies if i retreated before defeating your air.  i think the answer is no, i would not have killed them, to kill them i would have to continue the air battle… what do you think?

  • 12

    i mean, i could still have killed them and still retreated before defeating
    your air, but ONLY if the sub had hit twice during the battle rounds after
    round 2.


  • if your sub hit while the battle was going on, a transport would have died.

    your sub wouldn’t automatically kill when I still had units defending.  if both of our air wiped, your sub would have then killed both transports automatically

  • 12

    @hobo:

    if your sub hit while the battle was going on, a transport would have died.

    your sub wouldn’t automatically kill when I still had units defending.  if both of our air wiped, your sub would have then killed both transports automatically

    Yep I think thats right.


  • I see where you going, since my air can’t hit your sub and eventually you’d hit, but you had to stay in the battle. if you retreated you would have to retreat with the sub as well.

Suggested Topics

  • 25
  • 32
  • 32
  • 82
  • 49
  • 18
  • 340
  • 70
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

32

Online

17.9k

Users

40.7k

Topics

1.8m

Posts