Star Wars is just another franchise now; it will have highs and lows but it can’t re-bottle the magic and wonder of the OT. It’s essentially in the same boat as James Bond.
And as long as James Earl Jones has working vocal chords you can bet we’ll hear plenty more Vader appearances.
And as long as James Earl Jones has working vocal chords you can bet we’ll hear plenty more Vader appearances.
Noooooooooooooooooooo!
Rouge one Trailer #2 (more like an extended one)
@aequitas:
Rouge one Trailer #2 (more like an extended one)
This gives some hope. It at least looks good.
TFA was Not quiet my expectation.
I liked it for the effects and to see a SW movie again.
But the plot??
I hope R1 is more dedicated to the original story.
Don’t care if it is more of a war movie because Star WARS says allready that it is not about petting
a cat. 8-)
ROGUE ONE over EP VII, Hands down!!
That is SW as we know it!
a must see.
Yeah, I saw it Thursday night.
Better than Force Awakens (I still haven’t watched that one a 2nd time)
I wasn’t exactly blown away, though. Although I loved the views from the fighters, but they broke away from them too quickly - would have loved to have had 5-8 seconds
Also loved the panoramic views (which Episode VII also had) but too short for me
Too slow and boring the first half, but part of the trouble was our volume wasn’t loud enough. It’s torture not to have the volume control.
And - What General Veers said….
I was more satisfied after seeing Rogue One versus The Force Awakens, and this was in very large part to one very pleasant surprise appearance from a classic character.
I agree the cinematography was weak overall, and there were chunks of the first half that could have been left of the chopping room floor. My biggest takeaway from Rogue One is that this is distinctly a Star Wars action movie with a very different feel from the others. It makes sense since this is a standalone film that does not need to spend much time on character development or exposition.
Haven’t seen it yet, plan to this week sometime.
However… calling it better than Force Awakens is not exactly high praise to me. Considering Force Awakens may be last on my list.
No kidding, Mr. Hoffman :)
General, wasn’t the pleasant surprise appearance of your crush just computer trickery?
Maybe you should invest in a hologram projector for your home so you can see her and her glorious buns any time you want :lol:
Ha, I could have gone without that cameo in the end, I was talking about bringing Peter Cushing back from the dead! I loved his scenes and could have seen a whole movie devoted to early Imperial career maneuvering and backstabbing.
:-)
@aequitas:
ROGUE ONE over EP VII, Hands down!!
That is SW as we know it!
a must see.
no intentional spoilers but you might piece some together with stuff I say
This is most certainly not “SW as we know it.” It is a tremendously tonally uneven movie. My impression from the previews that there might have been something there before they “focus-grouped the shit out of it” was largely born out. I know this because the line from the trailer “I rebel” didn’t make the final cut. I can see why around the time of the highly publicized re-shoots they were talking about the movie “not feeling like Star Wars.” What was “focus-grouped out of it” was the highly cynical underlying story. The movie was also just full of the crap cinematic sensibilities of modern product cinema. Scope and shaky cam do not go together. Why film a movie in 2:35:1 only to fill it full of claustrophobic close-ups where you bounce the frame around?
There is some neat stuff in there with regards the space battle but the use of actual footage from Star Wars was jarring as all get out. I find myself hard pressed to remember the names of any of the characters not the main girl. The script was not a mess but didn’t earn any of the emotional beats it aimed for and just sort of bumbled into something resembling a point and the whole thing is salvaged or more salved by the very end of the movie which keeps it from being an utter downer trip to the movies.
I don’t even remember the main girl’s name :lol:
Rey or something? :lol:
Aside from the Essos of the new characters in this I’d have to look at a cast list to do more than be guessing at their names. I’m really curious what the movie looked like before the re-shoots or whatever they showed the earliest test audiences. The more I think about the script/screenplay the more I hate it.
One snippet I’m curious about is the scene of Jyn being face-to-face with a TIE Fighter on the catwalk of the deflector array that was in the trailers but cut out of the film. Was it part of a possible getaway?
One snippet I’m curious about is the scene of Jyn being face-to-face with a TIE Fighter on the catwalk of the deflector array that was in the trailers but cut out of the film. Was it part of a possible getaway?
Still haven’t seen it, but…
My brother mentioned this yesterday when I got his opinion on the movie. FWIW.
He is a Donald Trump Huge Star Wars fan. Lives and breathes it you could say. His statement to me is that it was in his top 4 SW films thus far, but he needed to see it again to determine where he would put it.
While I am not actively seeking out spoilers, I am not avoiding them either. I figure that I know the beginning and the end, so the middle is not going to be much of a surprise.
I appreciate your detailed and critical take as always Frimmel.
What I’d compare it too is “Pearl Harbor” or “Titanic” only the first half isn’t quite as boring as either of those. You get to the big thing happening like the attack starting and the ship hitting the iceberg and the movie becomes much more interesting. I don’t care to see the whole thing again but I’d watch from just before they leave to steal the plans till the end again. The neat things are really neat and much of everything else is a pile of “meh.”
I’d have liked it much better without the shaky-cam which I tend to think is a trait of directors who don’t actual believe in their material and as I think more about the tonal unevenness I’m inclined to pin that on a cynic trying to make a sort of traditional patriotic war movie and badly copying “Saving Private Ryan.” But he didn’t believe any of it. Maybe I’m trying to say the film was trying to be both “The Green Berets” and “Born of the Fourth of July.”
And as I write that I find the idea coincides with my thoughts on Edwards’s “Godzilla” where I’d constantly get the idea that he’d made choices because they were cool without really understanding what made them cool.
Love it - especially 1st paragraph
