GARGANTUA'S $200 TOURNAMENT OF EXTRA DEATH AND PAIN (TripleA Only) 2xELIMINATION

[Gargantua]

At this stage….

After 10 days of NO correspodence (so long as you have attempted to contact them).  Let me know, and I will decide.

[Cow]

Rules against taking partner’s turn? limitations?

[Nothing to see here]

How abou aouask your opponent at the start of the game if it’s allright with them. That’s what we did.

[Cow]

What happens if a game just refuses to end? What determines the winner?

[Cow]

I think it should be done with judges that way people don’t stall toward the end to maintain whatever criteria for winning there is.

[Cow]

At the same time though, composite TUV, unit count, and production should be taken into consideration.

Also the nature of the game, axis win at certain VC opportunities, I do feel the burden falls on the axis to win, so you can easily fastforward a round for both sides to setup and then do an all in attack and defense for the VC to see who wins.

So we could make the burden fall on defending VCs, which is what the axis should be trying to go for. I am an aggressive player so I prefer a more objective oriented mechanism for determining a winner.

Plus judges can be very subjective. Fast forwarding and forcing the axis to attack for a VC makes more sense to me.

[Cow]

Never did a PBF tournament before, the live ones always had a winner.

[Cow]

By live I mean tripleA, I don’t believe in axis and allies face to face tournaments @ 2 hours a game (just seems so silly to have only 4-5 rounds).

[Noll]

Then you have Axis players on the loosing side that still have a decent tuv compare but reaching the downfall playing half turn in 15 days and you wonder wtf.
During my turn I didnt bomb a factory in fear of having to wait 5 days for an intercept roll. Frustrating.

[allweneedislove]

eskander, please look at the bracket and let me know if this is correct.

it looks like soul goo and the numenoreans can begin their 3rd round match.

OFFICIAL UNTIL PROVEN WRONG XDAP Tournament Bracketing 2012-10-5.xls

[allweneedislove]

changed name from extrabilly to WeWin as billyclub has been replaced by seththenewbe

OFFICIAL UNTIL PROVEN WRONG XDAP Tournament Bracketing 2012-10-5.xls

[allweneedislove]

clausiwitz’s idiot apprentices defeated speedo hares.

OFFICIAL UNTIL PROVEN WRONG XDAP Tournament Bracketing 2012-10-8.xls

[Degrasse]

Since Vold and I were both missing partners, he’s going to join the newly renamed Clausewitz’s Speedy Idiots for the next game.

[dutchmand]

Team BoldDutch over WeWin.

Next up, Norse Elite.

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=28544.465

[allweneedislove]

updated bracket with boldutch defeating wewin. and clauseitz’s speedy idiots name change.

boldutch can start their game with norse elite.
wewin is waiting for the winner of the headless neds vs the long dark tea time of the soul

OFFICIAL UNTIL PROVEN WRONG XDAP Tournament Bracketing 2012-10-22.xls

[allweneedislove]

updated bracket

cannibalized by fluff has defeated attack of the killa gorillas.

cannibalized by fluff awaits the loser of dairy qryn vs the final draft

OFFICIAL UNTIL PROVEN WRONG XDAP Tournament Bracketing 2012-10-28.xls

[Noll]

Whats the criteria to declare victory in a game that wasnt finished by the deadline?

[allweneedislove]

Bracket updated.

Team Third Floor graciously resigned before the game went to decision.
Creature Commando’s moves on to face the loser of unterhund vs imhotep.

OFFICIAL UNTIL PROVEN WRONG XDAP Tournament Bracketing 2012-10-31.xls

[allweneedislove]

@Noll:

Whats the criteria to declare victory in a game that wasnt finished by the deadline?

if the game was continued and played in the same style with even, which side is on the path to win by the game’s victory conditions.

or whatever team gargantua feels like.

i have sent garg a very short write up as to which sides are winning and why for the 5 games to be adjudicated.

[allweneedislove]

@Noll:

Whats the criteria to declare victory in a game that wasnt finished by the deadline?

if the game was continued and played in the same style with even DICE, which side is on the path to win by the game’s victory conditions.

or whatever team gargantua feels like.

i have sent garg a very short write up as to which sides are winning and why for the 5 games to be adjudicated.