Alsch (Axis) vs Auswanderersland and JamesAleman (Allies) Alpha 2
-
I’ll have to confer with Andy on this one…
-
Sure thing.
-
I asked for a ruling, however, I would like to point out the following:
Russia is not a “true” neutral. They are a member of the Allied forces and allow allied units in their territories in both maps once at war with Germany/Italy.
To give an example of why America may land planes is the following:
Germany is in Siberia, so America may never attack? That would silly.
-
I agree that would be strange, but would also be a relatively rare occurance.
I’d argue it would be much sillier for US to be able to land 12 bombers in Amur, wrecking Japan’s IC every turn, and for Japan not to be allowed to strike back without giving Russia 12 IPCs.A line from the Alpha rules-
Due to its separate treaties with Germany and Japan, the Soviet Union is in a unique position in its relationship with the Axis powers. As a result, if the Soviet Union is at war with Axis powers on only one map, it is still under the restrictions of being a neutral power (see Powers Not at War with One Another above) on the other map. In other words, a state of war with Japan lifts those restrictions from the USSR on the Pacific map only, and a state of war with Germany and/or Italy lifts those restrictions on the Europe map only.
-
/shakesfist at the world.
Alsch,
Our incorrect understanding of Russia’s neutrality has forced us to redo China and US Turn 5. We are discussing now, I should be able to repost after the kids go to bed. Sorry for the inconvinience. We will keep what rolls we can as it appeared they were slightly in your favor.
-
No worries. That’s fine.
-
USA turn 5: (Note on China, I didn’t roll for an inf in Kan, map shows right move, but I failed to update text/rolls)
Production: 82
6 Bombers=72
Save 10
72+10=82Combat Moves:
To Kor: 2inf,art,arm-Mid via 2trn-z25 vs inf-Kor (Keeping rolls, so only rolling for the inf,art)
Rolls: 2@2; Total Hits: 02@2: (4, 4)To z6: (same as before, keeping rolls) 3ftr,3tac-Mid; sub-z25 vs dd
Feel free to scramble and roll for 3 ftrs and finish battle if you like. -
Kor2: inf,art,arm vs inf
Rolls: 2@2 1@3; Total Hits: 22@2: (2, 5)1@3: (2)
Rolls: 1@2; Total Hits: 01@2: (6) -
z6: Japan lost dd; USA no loss
Kor: Japan lost inf; USA lost inf (I added the trn,inf,art because we could not get bomber into this battle, hope that is ok)Noncombat Moves:
To z62: sub-z26
To z25 3ftr,3tac-z6
To z63: sub-z54
To z26: trn-z10 loaded with UKarm,USAinf-Wus
To Haw: inf-z26; 6ftr-z25
To Que: 10 bmbrs-Wus (I may switch this back to 7 and leave 3 in Wus, need to have Andy confirm. He’ll do it when he posts UK)Placement:
Wus: 6 bmbrsCollection: 88 (78+10saved)
-
China as before: Turn 5
Production: 5
Inf=3
Save=2
Combat Moves:
To Sui: inf-She uncontested
To Kan: inf-Tsi; inf,ftr-She vs inf (keeping rolls, just rolling for my missing inf)
Rolls: 1@1; Total Hits: 01@1: (3) -
Kan2: inf,ftr vs inf
Rolls: 1@1 1@3; Total Hits: 11@1: (2)1@3: (2)
Rolls: 1@2; Total Hits: 01@2: (5) -
Kan: Japan lost inf; China lost inf
Noncombat Moves:
To Sui: 11 inf (leaving 1 to prevent blitz)
To Tsi: ftr-Kan
Placement:
Tsi: infCollection: 7 (5+2saved)
-
Adjusted USA income to 83: They no longer have Phi NO
-
Uk turn 5:
London: 20
2 Trn=14
1 inf=3
Save 3India: 21
5 art=20
Save 1
Combat Moves:
To Shn: 2inf-Bur; ftr-Ind; 2 tac-z39 vs 2 inf
Rolls: 2@1 2@3 1@4; Total Hits: 22@1: (3, 1)2@3: (4, 2)1@4: (5)
Rolls: 2@2; Total Hits: 12@2: (2, 3)
To Eir: inf-Sco uncontested -
Shn: Japan lost 2 inf; UK lost inf
Noncombat Moves:
To z80: bb,cv,2dd-z39; ftr-Tsi; ftr-Ind; dd,2ca,2trn-z71 loaded with 2inf,2art
To Saf: 2inf,art-Rho
To Cpr: 2inf,2art-z80; 4inf,art-Irq
To Epr: mech,arm-Irq; 7mech-Ind
To Ind: 6inf,8art,7mech,arm,aagun-Bur; ftr,2tac-Shn
To Uk: ftr-106; 5inf,6art,aagun,2ftr-Sco
To z63: trn-z85 loaded with inf,art-Bra
To Nze: inf,art-z63
To z26: ca-z28
To Cus: inf-WusPlacement:
z71: trn
Saf: inf
Ind: 5artCollection:
London: 29 (26+3saved)
India: 10 (9+1Saved) -
Uk will scramble to prevent Italian landings on Eir or Sco
UK trn went to far, goes to z51 instead of Nze
-
Anzac turn 5:
Production: 24
Minor factory=12
1 infantry=3
2 artillery=8Noncombat Moves:
To Ind: ftr-She
To Que: 6inf,aagun-Sau; ftr-z62; 3inf,art-NswPlacement:
Que: minor factory
Nsw: inf,2artCollection: 16 (15+1Saved)
-
Forgot to place extra trn in z71 on UK build.
-
changing anzac noncombat:
Leaving 2art,4 inf in SauAdjusted IPCs to correct Anzac balance of 16
-
Suggested Topics
