Noll/Axis/jim vs ghr2/corr/jen Alpha 3

  • Customizer

    Not good enough.  Move the BB from 110 to 111 and put the carrier back in Gib and I’d be happy with the UK.

  • 18 17 16 11 Mod

    Move the SZ 98 fleet to SZ 91, move the Italian DD/TRn back and don’t touch anything else and I’ll be happy with England being balanced.  You can still do Sea Lion, or Modified Sea Lion (round 4 instead of round 3) but England can be more secure - not to mention you don’t negate England hitting the Italians in Taranto if they want to live on the edge.

  • Customizer

    I could live with that.

  • 18 17 16 11 Mod

    So for this round, should we go with those two changes?


  • Can I switch for Italy?


  • I’d like to keep Italy.


  • :(  I would liek to be with at least 1 of my buds :)


  • So are we using Krieg’s, Jen’s and Jim’s suggestions?

    To recap:

    Krieg
    DD in 106 becomes a CA
    French CA in 112 moves to 110
    British CA in 112 moves to 111

    Jim
    British BB in 110 moves to 111

    Jen
    Britch CV, TAC, DD, CA fr 98 to 91


  • I encourage players to accept the random assignment as it is one of the best and most fair ways to keep the game fresh for people, but I allow for trades because I understand.

    If you are ok with your random assignment and ok with the modifications, post a thumbs up, happy face, yes, yay, ya or some other affirmation.  Otherwise, ask for a change.


  • I don’t mind playing with anyone, I love playing with Jim and Axisplaya, so if for gh2 it’s so important to play with Jenn and Corrigan I can change side and go Allies with them. Although I agree that keeping the random play we could basically re-play these group of people for #infinite# number of plays :P

    But are we using standard rules? 'Cause I’m not willing to play for example an USA that’s delayed to end of turn 8 for a dow.


  • We are not using my modifications.


  • @Noll:

    I don’t mind playing with anyone, I love playing with Jim and Axisplaya, so if for gh2 it’s so important to play with Jenn and Corrigan I can change side and go Allies with them. Although I agree that keeping the random play we could basically re-play these group of people for #infinite# number of plays :P

    But are we using standard rules? 'Cause I’m not willing to play for example an USA that’s delayed to end of turn 8 for a dow.

    I just like playign with jim or corrigan


  • If we don’t change things I’m Italy and who’s playing Germany and Japan?


  • I am Germany right now.

    If Jim accepts his random assignment, then he’s got the USSR and actually that would put him on the same team as Ryan (aka “GHR”).

    However, Jen and Jim talked about a trade, and that would put Jen playing the USSR again, and Jim playing Japan.


  • Well, as I said, I’d like to play Italy. I’m Italian! Forza ragazzi! Dux mea lux!


  • Krieg
    DD in 106 becomes a CA
    French CA in 112 moves to 110
    British CA in 112 moves to 111
    German trans fr 113 to 114

    Jim
    British BB in 110 moves to 111

    Jen
    British CV, TAC, DD, CA fr 98 to 91

  • 10

    personally, i think we should playtest Krieg’s set up, since it has the most chances to become official.

  • 18 17 16 11 Mod

    @Axisplaya:

    personally, i think we should playtest Krieg’s set up, since it has the most chances to become official.

    Agreed, although my suggestion is the least impactful on the game. :P


  • @Axisplaya:

    personally, i think we should playtest Krieg’s set up, since it has the most chances to become official.

    I agree too


  • I’m willing to play either with Jim’s, Jen’s and Krieg’s mods or just Krieg’s.

    If there is someone that just has to play Germany to be happy - I’ll trade, but I really believe in randomizing sides.

    so I’m ready to go – can everyone just send a nod so that I know that we have or haven’t come to an agreement.

Suggested Topics

  • 53
  • 512
  • 359
  • 440
  • 177
  • 189
  • 557
  • 515
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

41

Online

17.9k

Users

40.7k

Topics

1.8m

Posts