Noll (Allies) vs. corriganbp (Axis) Hopefully normal rematch, A3 as of 11.17.11

[corriganbp]

Germany 1
Purchase AC, 2 transports
Combat

Attack SZ 106 (dst) with 2 subs fr 103 & 117
AttackerRolls: 2@2; Total Hits: 12@2: (6, 2)
DefenderRolls: 1@2; Total Hits: 01@2: (5)

Attack SZ 109 (dst+up to 4 ftrs) with 2 subs fr 108 & 118, bmb fr e germ, ftr fr Holland, ftr 2 tacs fr w germ

AttackerRolls: 2@2 2@3 3@4; Total Hits: 32@2: (2, 6)2@3: (5, 5)3@4: (1, 2, 6)
DefenderRolls: 1@2; Total Hits: 01@2: (6)

Attack SZ 111 (bship dst up to 1 ftr) with sub fr 124, bmb/tac fr e germ, ftr fr Norway, ftr tac fr w germ,

AttackerRolls: 1@2 2@3 3@4; Total Hits: 31@2: (4)2@3: (5, 2)3@4: (1, 3, 5)
DefenderRolls: 1@2 1@4; Total Hits: 01@2: (3)1@4: (5)

Attack SZ 112 (2 cruisers) with bship, cruiser fr 113, ftr fr Hungary, tac fr W Poland

AttackerRolls: 2@3 2@4; Total Hits: 32@3: (1, 4)2@4: (3, 2)
DefenderRolls: 2@3; Total Hits: 02@3: (6, 6)

Attack Normandy (1 inf 1 art) with inf and tank fr Holland, 2 mechs fr W Germany

AttackerRolls: 3@1 1@3; Total Hits: 23@1: (1, 5, 5)1@3: (1)
DefenderRolls: 2@2; Total Hits: 02@2: (6, 5)

Attack paris (6 inf 2 art 2 tnks ftr aa gun) with 3 inf 2 art 2 tnks fr Holland, 3 inf 1 art 2 mech fr w germ, 3 tanks fr s germ
6 inf 2 mech 3 art 5 tanks vs. aa 6 inf 2 art 2 tnks ftr

AttackerRolls: 5@1 6@2 5@3; Total Hits: 105@1: (1, 2, 4, 3, 1)6@2: (2, 1, 1, 3, 6, 1)5@3: (1, 4, 3, 2, 1)
DefenderRolls: 8@2 2@3 1@4; Total Hits: 68@2: (1, 5, 6, 1, 2, 3, 3, 2)2@3: (2, 4)1@4: (1)

Attack Yugoslavia (5 inf) with 3 tanks fr Poland, Hungary and Romania, 6 inf 1 art fr s Germany, 2 inf fr Hungary, 1 inf fr Romania

9 inf 1 art 3 tanks vs. 5 inf

AttackerRolls: 8@1 2@2 3@3; Total Hits: 68@1: (1, 5, 6, 6, 5, 1, 3, 2)2@2: (1, 5)3@3: (3, 2, 2)
DefenderRolls: 5@2; Total Hits: 15@2: (2, 3, 3, 6, 5)

[corriganbp]

SZ 106 taken without loss

SZ 109 taken without loss

SZ 111 cleared without loss

SZ 112 taken without loss

Normandy taken without loss

Attack paris (6 inf 2 art 2 tnks ftr aa gun) with 3 inf 2 art 2 tnks fr Holland, 3 inf 1 art 2 mech fr w germ, 3 tanks fr s germ
2 mech 3 art 5 tanks vs. 1 tnks ftr

AttackerRolls: 5@2 5@3; Total Hits: 25@2: (2, 5, 3, 3, 4)5@3: (5, 4, 2, 6, 4)
DefenderRolls: 1@3 1@4; Total Hits: 11@3: (2)1@4: (6)

Yugo taken with 1 inf lost

[corriganbp]

SZ 106 taken without loss

SZ 109 taken without loss

SZ 111 cleared without loss

SZ 112 taken without loss

Normandy taken without loss

Paris taken with loss of 6 inf and 1 mech

Yugo taken with 1 inf lost

Lady luck, she one mean crazy b*&^#.

And here you have the weirdness of Axis and Allies.  Identical openings – radically different outcomes.  Without low luck, I am not sure if we can come to any definitive conclusions when people have a “prove it to me” attitude.  I guess the best we can do is trust to Larry, and use a bid system to express our personal beliefs.  But it is just so gosh darn obvious to me that this current set up is heavily pro axis.

Axis and Allies is more like our national sport of baseball, where the best teams might win 60% of the time.  You just can’t prove anything quickly.

Landing orders

Tac fr e germ lands on AC in 112
Bmbs to w germ
1 ftr fr 109 lands on AC in 112
2 ftrs fr 111 land in w germ
1 ftr in 112 lands in w germ
2 tacs fr 109 to Holland
1 ftr fr 109 to Holland
2 tacs fr 111 to Holland

NCM
1 inf fr Norway to Finland, activate 4 inf in Finland
1 inf fr Romania to Bulgaria, activate 4 inf in Bulgaria
2 inf fr Norway to W Germ via trans
2 inf fr Denmark to W Germn
3 aa guns fr w germ to Holland
1 art fr S Germ to W Germ
11 inf 3 arts 3 aa fr e germ to w germ
3 inf fr e germ to w germ

This is pretty close to the best I came hope for with G1.

Germany collects 70 ipcs

[Noll]

I agree that the Axis looks like they have a slight advantage. But I won’t say the game is terribly umbalanced.

I’d say it’s a 55 or maybe 60/40

[corriganbp]

change in the ncm orders

11 inf 3 arts 3 aa fr e germ to s germ

3 inf fr w poland to hungary

map attached.

G1.AAM

[Noll]

I think you uploaded the wrong map

[corriganbp]

see updated map

G1.AAM

[Noll]

Russia#1

IPCs: 37

Builds
1tac (11)
5mec (20)
1arm (6)

NCM on map;

mobilize

1tac RUS
2mec 1arm SUKR
3mec NOV

Collects: 37

01_Corrigan_vs_Noll_01bRUS.AAM

[corriganbp]

Japan 1
Activate 3 transports, save 5 ipcs

Combat
1 inf fr Jehol to Cha
1 inf 1 art fr Jeh to Anh
Mech fr Man to Anh
3 inf 1 art fr sha to anh
3 inf 1 art fr ksu to anh

Attack Hun 2 inf with 3 inf 1 art fr ksi,  ftr fr Formosa, 2 ftrs 2 tacs fr man
3 inf 1 art 3 ftrs 2 tacs vs. 2 inf

AttackerRolls: 2@1 2@2 3@3 2@4; Total Hits: 42@1: (3, 5)2@2: (2, 2)3@3: (5, 2, 4)2@4: (2, 5)
DefenderRolls: 2@2; Total Hits: 22@2: (2, 1)

Attack yun with 2 bmbs from Japan, ftr tac fr Ksu, 3 inf 1 art fr kwa vs 4 inf
3 inf 1 art ftr tac 2 bmbs vs. 4 inf

AttackerRolls: 2@1 2@2 1@3 3@4; Total Hits: 32@1: (2, 3)2@2: (3, 2)1@3: (6)3@4: (6, 2, 2)
DefenderRolls: 4@2; Total Hits: 34@2: (2, 2, 2, 5)

[corriganbp]

Hunan taken with loss of 2 inf

Attack yun with 2 bmbs from Japan, ftr tac fr Ksu, 3 inf 1 art fr kwa vs 4 inf
3 inf 1 art ftr tac 2 bmbs vs. 4 inf

AttackerRolls: 1@2 1@3 3@4; Total Hits: 21@2: (3)1@3: (4)3@4: (3, 6, 3)
DefenderRolls: 1@2; Total Hits: 01@2: (3)

[corriganbp]

Hunan taken with loss of 2 inf

Yunan taken with loss of 3 inf

Amazing performance by the Chinese infantry.

Landing Orders
All planes except 3 ftrs 3 tacs land in Kwa
3 ftrs and 3 tacs land in 36

NCM
1 art fr Man, 1 inf fr Oki to Kwa
1 inf and 1 art fr Japan to Kwa
6 inf aa fr Man to Jeh
4 inf fr Korea to Man
1 inf 1 tank fr Japan to Korea
Rest of fleet except 1 trans (in SZ 6) to 36

Japan collects 40 ipcs saved 5 = 45 ipcs

01_Corrigan_vs_Noll_01bJAP.AAM

[corriganbp]

….

[Noll]

dots?

[corriganbp]

posting a message so that I could include the response “notify me of replies”

[Noll]

Please save the files like this:

aGermany
bRussia
cJapan

this way they will be in a nice order :)

[Noll]

US builds 2cv 1dd 2ss (52ipcs)

NCM on map.

Builds
2cv sz10
2ss 1dd sz101;

collects 52 (tts)

01_Corrigan_vs_Noll_01cJAP.AAM

[Noll]

China#1

builds 4inf (12)

Combat Moves:

2inf KWE > YUN (1rtl)
1inf 1fig SZE > YUN
Rolls: 3@1 1@3; Total Hits: 13@1: (6, 2, 4)1@3: (3)
Rolls: 1@2; Total Hits: 01@2: (4)

[Noll]

Yunnan twol.

NCM as map

places 4inf SZE

Collects: 9(tt)+6(no) = 15

01_Corrigan_vs_Noll_01eCHINA.AAM

[Noll]

UK#1

UKL ipcs: 28

1fig (10)
6inf (18)

UKP ipcs: 17
4inf (12)
1aa (5)

Combat Moves:

sz96 (1dd 1tr)
! 1ca 1tac sz98
! 1fig mal
Rolls: 2@3 1@4; Total Hits: 22@3: (2, 6)1@4: (3)
Rolls: 1@2; Total Hits: 01@2: (3)

[Noll]

sz96 cleared

NCM as map

Mobilize:
6inf 1fig London
4inf 1aa Calcutta

Collects:

UKL 28+5 = 33 -convoys:

sz106 (max3)
Rolls: 4@3; Total Hits: 04@3: (5, 4, 4, 4)
sz109 (max8)
Rolls: 4@3; Total Hits: 04@3: (4, 5, 4, 5)