@nikola1975 said in PTV L25 PlayOff: Surfer (Allies) vs Nikola1975 (Axis +9):
@surfer Yes :) Let’s see how you react.
Ok. Let’s try this. Scramble orders?
11L Game 3, '41 Ol'Blood&Guts (x) v. Boldfresh (9) no tech
-
in other words, what I’m saying OBG is I don’t see why it’s not perfectly valid to use the second roll of ukr as the round 2 roll. i think dice as rolled should always be used if possible, and all you would need to do in this case is remove one of your twos from the second round roll and the battle is decided. that and the disallowing of the battle of bst and we should be good. but i’m certainly willing to have an objective third party look at this if you insist. again, the only reason i rerolled the battle was so you could not object, thinking I had an unfair advantage of seeing a positive roll then adding a combat move. the roll was GOOD for me, not bad. you aren’t thinking that I added the combat move in order to reroll the round 1 because I was not happy with 1 attacker hit, 0 defender hits are you?
just think about it and let me know if you still do not agree.
-
Actually, I thought your entire move after your first post was illegally done since you posted and rolled…and thus should be redone after the first attack in Ukraine. Fruit of the poisonous tree so to speak. However, I tried to be amicable by agreeing to allow Bry and Bel to stand when I did not have to do so in my eyes. But since you insist on going through all this, I sent a message to JWW saying no ruling would be needed since I am resigning. I would rather be done with it and do not want a similar situation like you had with gamerman. Good luck to you and I ask that you refrain from posting any comments in my other games. You may post your victory. Thank you.
-
@Ol’:
Actually, I thought your entire move after your first post was illegally done since you posted and rolled…and thus should be redone after the first attack in Ukraine. Fruit of the poisonous tree so to speak. However, I tried to be amicable by agreeing to allow Bry and Bel to stand when I did not have to do so in my eyes. But since you insist on going through all this, I sent a message to JWW saying no ruling would be needed since I am resigning. I would rather be done with it and do not want a similar situation like you had with gamerman. Good luck to you and I ask that you refrain from posting any comments in my other games. You may post your victory. Thank you.
OBG, that seems like a bit of an over-reaction. Why not just let the moderators rule on it? I am not in the slightest bit upset about the issue and sure hope you reconsider. not sure why you would reference the Gamerman incident, that was not even remotely related to a procedural issue like this, it stemmed from much deeper issues going back many years to our childhoods.
in fact, if you had said that if I didn’t agree to re-roll in ukraine as you suggested, you would consider it worthy of resigning, i would have gladly complied. i was just trying to reason with you. if you consider following exact protocol of some sort, i could certainly do so.
please reconsider. we’ve had two very good games and this promised to be a very good finale… if it’s either re-roll ukraine or have you resign, i will re-roll…
-
I wanted a moderator ruling because it is an objective third party, not because I was at all upset. I thought we had agreed to let the moderators rule and that I would comply with the ruling. In the meantime I was hoping we could still come to an agreement on our own. Why the sudden change of heart?
-
Not to mention you are in the hunt for the league title and you have at least a 40 percent chance of winning this game. Look I’ll agree to forego the moderator ruling (I’m pretty sure I know how it would go anyway) and refill the entire round if you wish. If so, would you be willing to allow me to make the bst attack? If not, would you allow a Russian walking to Finland? Even if you will allow neither, I nevertheless offer to reroll the entire round. Remember, its just a game right? :-)
Finally, the issues between gamerman and myself were personal in nature and have absolutely no bearing on any of my other games whatsoever.
-
Ok…you are right in that it is just a game. While I still do not think you should have rerolled without concurrance, go ahead and make the noncoms without the Kar to Bst on the board. One rolling at 2 would probably miss in Ukraine anyhow.
-
-
Jap3-Buy: IC, 4 arm, 2 sub, dd…save 0
CM
- inf Fuk/art Kia/inf Jap/6ftr sz62 => Bry 3inf
- inf Fic/inf art arm Bur/inf Ind/cru bb sz37/2ftr sz35 => Egy 7inf art arm
- inf Ind => Trj
Bry
A-2inf art 6ftr
Rolls: 1@1 2@2 6@3; Total Hits: 31@1: (4)2@2: (4, 4)6@3: (3, 5, 1, 4, 5, 2)
D-3inf
Rolls: 3@2; Total Hits: 03@2: (6, 6, 4) -
Bry twol
Egy
A-3inf art arm 2ftr cru bb
Rolls: 2@1 2@2 4@3 1@4; Total Hits: 62@1: (1, 1)2@2: (3, 5)4@3: (1, 2, 4, 1)1@4: (4)
D-7inf art arm
Rolls: 8@2 1@3; Total Hits: 38@2: (3, 2, 3, 5, 4, 2, 3, 5)1@3: (3) -
Egy
A-art arm 2ftr
Rolls: 1@2 3@3; Total Hits: 41@2: (2)3@3: (1, 1, 1)
D-inf art arm
Rolls: 2@2 1@3; Total Hits: 12@2: (1, 6)1@3: (4) -
Egy twlo 3inf art
NCM
2inf Bur => Yun
cv sz35 => sz34
2ftr Egy => sz34
6ftr Bry => sz62
trn sz35 => sz36
dd sz62 => sz51
dd sz62 => sz57
sub sz62 => sz59Mobilize
IC in FIC
2sub dd in sz62
3arm in Man
arm in JapCollect: 58
-
Sorry I was on vacation.
Has this been resolved?
-
Yes we did resolve it…thanks!
-
Okay.
Just PM me if anything comes up.
-
bump
-
well obg, let’s see if i can’t remember what i was doin…
UK with 36 buys des (8), acc (14), 3 inf, arm (14)
CM
man () - sbr with bom (chi)
pol () - inf (gbr)
bst (inf) - 2 inf (gbr), bombard with bat, 2 ftr (z5)
rho (arm) - 2 inf (cng)
fin () - arm (nwy)combat:
sbr man
Rolls: 1@6; Total Hits: 11@6: (2)bst - 2 inf, 2 ftr, bat vs. inf
Rolls: 2@1 2@3 1@4; Total Hits: 22@1: (2, 5)2@3: (4, 2)1@4: (2)
Rolls: 1@2; Total Hits: 11@2: (1) -
2 damage to man, bst cwlo inf
rho - 2 inf vs. arm
Rolls: 2@1; Total Hits: 02@1: (6, 3)
Rolls: 1@3; Total Hits: 11@3: (2) -
never fails. let’s just go to the death
rho - inf vs. arm
Rolls: 10@1; Total Hits: 110@1: (4, 4, 4, 4, 2, 5, 1, 6, 3, 5)
Rolls: 10@3; Total Hits: 510@3: (3, 2, 6, 2, 2, 4, 5, 1, 6, 5) -
those guys were blind, deaf AND stupid, and most deserving to die a painful death.
rho holds, no losses.
NC
sol - inf (wca)
fin - inf (nwy)
z5 - 2 ftr (bst)
chi - bom (man)place 3 inf, arm (gbr)
place des, acc (z2)collect 29, has 29
-
Welcome back Dad! I hope the family is doing well!
Your posted noncoms has the bmr from Manchuria landing in China, yet your map has it in Yakut. I will move it to China on my map. If you meant Yakut, then just move it there on the US turn.
Ita3-Buy: 5 inf…save 0
CM
1. 2inf 2arm Bul/2arm Cze => Ukr 5inf 2armUkr
A-2inf 4arm
Rolls: 2@1 4@3; Total Hits: 22@1: (6, 5)4@3: (4, 6, 1, 2)
D-5inf 2arm
Rolls: 5@2 2@3; Total Hits: 35@2: (1, 6, 2, 6, 3)2@3: (6, 3)
Suggested Topics
