I think you just made your plan worse.
I pointed out that the attack on G3 isn’t strong enough to take London. You have just made your G3 attack weaker, which means that london definlity isn’t falling.
Sealion Stats- Cliff Notes
-
Jim, Axis, have you guys considered what happens when you don’t send 5 planes + 2 subs to that sz, JUST to kill a battleship/cruiser? You should sus those options…. they make for an amazing G1.
I’ve toyed with this one. I’ll try it at some point, but I just have a hard time letting that BB go.
I think with a minimal investment by US(1 CV 1 dd 1 tac or ftr) and the UK doing everything in its power to save its capital it is possible to defend a G3. But if Germ wants UK they can still take it G4.
I’ve toyed with this too. The counter I use is a hit and fade to Scotland. Hit for 2 rounds and back off back to London. Risky for UK, but it is the only thing I’ve come up with to counter it. Risky because once I hit so well with the UK that I killed all the germans and got stuck there.
-
yeah i’m with you on your comments jim- I can’t let that BB go- UK can make serious move to revive that navy quickly.
Strafe on Scotland? Hmmm…interesting.
-
That’s the thing.
If you guys are like me - and I think you are, you are always looking to move every piece you have on the board.
Tell me… what are you german aircraft and subs doing G2? Not a whole lot of much… If you skinned your knees with just ground units in paris, and killed off the BB.
You talk about the BB “going away” there’s no where for it to “go away” to. Save inside the Med, where it’s still just a FAT target. Trust me, you get it G2…
It’s all about the fall of Normandy, and if you have some luck, winning a 50/50 draw in southern france.
It also entices some players to try and build into their british fleet, or exhaust their planes in an attack against the german one. Making sea-lion SO much easier, and barely half the investment. And with the odd ground unit you save, by crushing paris, and taking normandy/ maybe southern france off the list, YOu end up with more mechanized units on the ground, and a more focused Italian troop.
To boot, this build makes the option for the british to attack the italians, that much more unviable. In most cases, allowing the Italian fleet to survive. Then, hell… you got a game.
IT WORKS, try it. just don’t let it get out of hand :)
-
I’ll try it in one of my games
-
Scotland is so good to take because if they come back for it their just making their Capital slimmer and like I like to say why wait for them to build round after round.
Strafing targets with your planes in most cases its a good thing sometimes ya get burned, when they do it to you and you find the hot dice it can be very rewarding…… it happened last weekend and I annihilated a bunch of planes, I was Russia it was great!!! the dice were my friends -
I’ve improved my German/Italian strategy to the point that if the US doesn’t committ anything to Europe, the allies will lose - and lose bad.
Even if Japan is wiped off the board by US8, which, isn’t likely to happen. Without intervention of somekind by the US, into the mediterranean or otherwise, the Axis will win in Europe - nye guarunteed.
This can be compounded with a micro Japanese campaign against the Russians in the east - eroding the red income.
Try it on the Europe board. Take the U.S. right out of the game. The Allies don’t stand a chance. Thats also considering Germany gets 2 less IPC’s from the Paris capture, and the reds give a full committment against germany, with no troop draws to japan, and no chance of income erosion in the east.
All theories of a 100% American committment to Japan are hereby debunked.
And just think of the Japanese counter options, if you know the yanks are coming, and you only have to play a delay game…
I Axis have lost some games and won others when the US went Japan first in the games I play with my friend. We have averaged about a game every 2 weeks since Alpha 2 came out. The tactic we are having more trouble overcoming is when the USA reduces Italy to no longer being relevant first while flying fighters to Hawaii. Japan can still take Hawaii but it seems to cost too many resources with a bunch of Infantry and Fighters sitting there. Once Italy has been wrecked and their are US subs sitting in the Med, it seems very hard for the Axis to win in Europe so the US then bounces to the Pacific.
-
That’s the thing.You talk about the BB “going away” there’s no where for it to “go away” to. Save inside the Med, where it’s still just a FAT target. Trust me, you get it G2…
Well, this is the part i just don’t get…How do you get the UK fleet on G2 after UK gathered all they have in sz92 on UK1 AND left a blocker in sz104.
For all the rest of what you say, i agree. I’ve played this opening a few times, and it’s cool not to be stressed about UK scrambling in sz110, taking out sz111, Paris and Normandy with loads of planes and gambling in Sfr. This opening allow to maximize the effect of combined Tanks + tacs in Fra.
-
If the BB and CA in sz110 are left alone, UK can hit sz112 with upto 5 fht, 1 DD, 2 CA, 1 BB
I would assume that you would then as Germany need to buy at least 1 more combat ship and forego the 2 TTs?
So that’s:
5 fht, 1 DD, 2 CA, 1 BB vs 1 DD, 5 fht, 1 CV, 1 dmg BB, 1 CAGermany wins 75%. If Germany loses the CA, however, the odds drop to 52% in favour of the UK.
You would be short 1 TT in this scenario, which means UK can prevent Sealion anyway.
-
You talk about the BB “going away” there’s no where for it to “go away” to. Save inside the Med, where it’s still just a FAT target. Trust me, you get it G2…
I think I would do it in a game where I wasn’t serious about Sealion. Buy 1 CV and 2 sb and then chase it down turn 2. I’d do that.
-
I think I would do it in a game where I wasn’t serious about Sealion. Buy 1 CV and 2 sb and then chase it down turn 2. I’d do that.
Same question as Gargantua : How would you do that if Uk leaves a blocker in sz104 and gather everything in sz92 ?…
Uk has options then, they can get out of the med, they can go to sz98 and regroup with UK pacific boats… -
He would have to block in 110 and in 111 or 119. Which means he’s splitting his fleet up for me anyway. He would block the north with a DD, and block 110 with a CA (or build a DD blocker).
By splitting, I think I would still be able to get at his fleet wtih planes and any subs that are not blocked. Just musing here.
-
OK, here’s what I would do. Sea movements only.
-
German NCM Sea only. Land 2 fht in Sit.
I assumed that there is 1 sb loss in sz91 and mutual kills in sz106. If both subs are alive - watch out.
-
I guess the question would be, how would you set it up to prevent an attack on your fleet.
-
The only viable move I see is to move the BB and DD to sz92 along with the sz98 fleet.
-
Anyway you slice the pie, the allies are playing YOUR game, as oppossed to their own game. That’s the purpose of the excercise.
-
But I don’t like that combined fleet in sz92. That would be brought back up to sz109 to combine with new purchases. Could be too strong to hit by turn 2.
-
Gar…you said it was possible to get the UK fleet on G2. I just absolutely don’t see how. The UK fleet is safe and won’t be destroyed if UK player doesn’t do something stupid.
That said, not attacking sz110 on G1 has several advantages, i won’t deny it. And as you said, the axis is setting the rythm of the game.
Jim, your last map for Uk is what i meant. But with a few mistakes: there can never be 3dd on UK1 in sz92 (dd sz106 is not in range of sz92). One CA is missing.
The point is that : If you don’t attack sz110 on G1, then UK got a fleet right from the start on sz92, and they’re going to keep it. True, it will take time before this fleet gets well positioned and finally gets serious threats against Ger or Italy, but it will happen at some point.
-
Yes, I have too many DDs.
However, I see that the fleet is safe in sz92, and can be brought back up to sz109 to combine with buys and ready to go for turn 3 back to Med or cover TTs.
That’s what I see, anyway.
-
And Gargantua, its been 2 months and I’m still waiting for you to move in our game.
:wink:
Suggested Topics
