Besides YOURSELF who do you think is the BEST A&A player on the site is?


  • @Gargantua:

    I want to form a shopping list of the ELITE Axis and Allies players.  For a currently undisclosed purpose at this time.

    I can appreciate that some of you may feel this question should be VERSION specific.  But I believe at the heart of the matter, it shouldn’t matter what version you play, there is a truth and quality inherent to the skill of the game.

    To some extent, I can agree with your sentiments.  However, the rules between versions can be very different. 
    Sometimes it’s that little difference in knowing the rules well enough to understand their nuances that can make good player be a great player.

    Perhaps it’s my age or limited playing time that I can commit, but I prefer to focus on only one rule set at a time.  I would rather be great at one version of the game then be average at all of them.

    @Gargantua:

    If you must know, the objective outcome of the question will pertain specifically to Global 1940.  But Any of the basic games including Classic, Europe, Pacific, Revised, 1942, E40, P40, Anniversary, can also be used as a gauge.

    My suggestion is to troll the tournament/league area for some of the players with better records.  That would be a good start.

    How big is your targetted list?


  • I have played Axis Roll back at AAMC and will say he is a fine player.  Both of them, as there are two.  Although I have only played one game on this forum, I’d say He(they) are the best players here I know of.   There are a lot of outstanding players in the world that do not use this forum.  If you think you are good and want some competition, sign up for a tourney at AAMC or DAAK.

    matt(stormss)


  • That is a good point about other online clubs.

    AAWC (http://axisandalliesworldclub.org/forums/index.php) is another online clube with quality players, but those players are mainly focused on 2nd / 3rd edition (CD-Rom)


  • So many great players.  Yoshi, Zhukov44, Gamerman, Func, Gargantua, Anchovy, axis_roll, and I’m sure I’m leaving people out.  I’m so glad I’ve found this place… I went from being barely the best player in my group to dominating it entirely.  Although my new level has brought the overall play of my group up as well.

    Though I mostly play AA50 '41–I don’t think I’ve seen anyone as consistently good as Yoshi at it.  Arm twisted and though we’ve never played, he gets my vote.


  • Soul I agree with you this place is great.

    I am used to only play AAR and I am yet to lose a game. However on here I have never won a game.

    This says two things:
    1.) My friends are rubbish
    2.) The players on here are very good

    I would say it is a combination of both

  • TripleA

    OOOO maybe I should figure out who the best player is on tripleA to go battle the best player from this forum.

    It’s been a long time since I’ve played zhukov. He only does PBEM and I stopped doing PBEM games and forfeited a bunch so it’s been ages since we’ve played :(.

    I will put faith in zhukov, because his win loss ratio justifies it. 19 wins - 1 loss out of 20 games for axis.  16 win 4 loss for allies. On this forum he’s positive as well.

    He is on the more tactical/conservative side. I am on the more aggressive/overall strategy side.
    ~

    dessert fox… PBEM and Forum games are very different than live games. In a real life game the dice is in your hands and sometimes you just want to roll some dice.

    I am already aggressive in online play. In real life I take aggression to an extreme and put a whole game on crack.
    ~

    online my russia tends to do battles I know I can win, unless I get a good 50/50 and my losses will be only inf and the chance I have for victory has a  huge payout. Real life games are totally different. Russia is balls deep half the time.


  • Hobbes 42. calvinhobbes most of them.

  • Customizer

    There is this guy … looks just like me.  Talks like me.  Acts like me.  Hell, he even goes by the same name I do!

    :-o


  • Let me guess is it……

    IL

    Bazinga

  • Customizer

    @The:

    Let me guess is it……

    IL

    Bazinga

    Only Doom can claim the crown - all others will be denied!

Suggested Topics

  • 7
  • 2
  • 7
  • 1
  • 3
  • 1
  • 7
  • 636
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

34

Online

17.8k

Users

40.5k

Topics

1.8m

Posts