Most over rated is Patton. He made no greater command decision than “charge”. Any jackass can do that (almost). I am sure you know the whole “blood and guts” nickname he had (and earned).
The worst General, by FAR was Clark. It is absolutely stunning they allowed him to live after the war. He should have been court martialed and hung for all of the American (and axis too) lives he wasted. Little story about this POS…
When he finaly broke through in Italy and was about to capture Rome it was mid afternoon when his caravan had to stop because there was some fighting going on up the road. We were mopping up some Germans who were cut off. Clark’s assistant asked “how long till we can get under way”. The guy in charge said it would probably take 4-5 hours. Clark wouldn’t allow it, he demanded it be cleared in 2 hours (and it was).
The reason why?
The sun was going down and the General wouldn’t be able to take good pictures in the twilight as he entered Rome.