@zlefin lets leave it as is. Normally one doesn’t allow these kinds of changes after dice have been rolled, but it wouldn’t have impacted the battle (your subs got the hits) and I appreciate you are new to league play. And I wouldn’t have scrambled given that htere were 2 battleships to soak to the hits.
Post League Game Results Here
-
@axis-dominion has been victorious in L24 bm4 axis-dom (axis) vs pacifier (allies+19) - rematch
-
L24 PTV MikawaGunichi X+8 vs dawgoneit
PTV MikawaGunichi X+8 wins
https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/40613/l24-ptv-mikawagunichi-x-8-vs-dawgoneit/91?_=1712405004646 -
PtV 23 dawgoneit (X+10) vs AetV
AetV Allies wins
https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/40130/ptv-23-dawgoneit-x-10-vs-aetv/100?_=1712405004648 -
PtV-Elche(x+11)-666(Allies)
666 wins
https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/40214/ptv-elche-x-11-666-allies/225
-
L24 BM4 Adam514 (Axis) vs axis-dominion (Allies+21) Rematch
axis-dominion wins!
-
@Adam514 what a truly epic match with so high level play by both sides. I have been taking strategy notes.
-
Incredible play on both parts think you could go another 20 turns on this one.
-
yah it’s amazing how resilient adam’s axis are, i had a number of significant battles that went well over the course of that long match and yet he kept bouncing back and it seemed like i will never be able take them down… toward the end i kept baiting him into going for a large naval battle, giving him greater and greater odds… this last turn i was debating a lot whether i went too far, which i probably did, but it worked out well after all lol…
looking forward to JDOW’s post game analysis, i already know i’m going to get a pretty hard critique of my pacific play hahaha
-
-
AetV (Allies+24) vs Simon33 (Axis) BM4
Simon33 over AetV
https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/40156/aetv-allies-24-vs-simon33-axis-bm4/124
-
That’s a win!
@mikawagunichi has no one else to beat, he is champion of the 2nd PTV bracket
🏆 -
@gamerman01 Thank you. Hopefully I can graduate to the main bracket next year.
-
PtV 23 ArtofWar1947 vs AetV (X+11)
AoW47 over AetV through bumping me out.
As I allready explained it to AoW47, i have no furthe interest in a game against him.
If it happens that we should have a game through Playoff, I will forefit it.https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/39928/ptv-23-artofwar1947-vs-aetv-x-11/263?page=11
-
@aequitas-et-veritas good call. If your desired playing speeds don’t match, best to find a different opponent. Just a game that should be enjoyed.
-
I had already granted a several month delay. After 6 days in a row of not responding–during which AetV was actively engaged in other games, I figured he had lost interest in our game. If at any time he had extended the courtesy of providing a heads up that he needed more time for any plausible reason, I would have gladly granted an extension. I did not post the game myself, because I wanted to give AetV an opportunity to continue the game. If he had informed he wanted a really slow paced game, it would have free me to take up another game.
-
@ArtofWar1947 sometimes games don’t work out. It happens.
-
PTV Guderian1 (X+10) vs mikawagunichi
Claiming over Guderian1 after 6 weeks of no responses.
https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/40574/l42-ptv-guderian1-x-10-vs-mikawagunichi/134?page=6
-
@ArtofWar1947 @aequitas-et-veritas
The way I’m reading it, there is maybe a misunderstanding.Art appeared to bump out the win, but aev reported it. When there is a bump out win, the winner always posts the win, unless the slow bumped out player agrees it’s over.
So I went in the thread and it looks like Art said hey, we can keep going,
but aequitas interpreted it that ArtofWar was demanding the win like a landlord demands rent.Which is it, guys? Seems like neither of you wants the game to end.
-
I did not bump out as the rules allow, because I wanted to AetV one final chance to continue our game at a reasonable pace. For example, the following delays seem unnecessary–
waiting from 3-29 @5:06 pm for an opponent to take his turnwaiting 2.5 days after making a non-surprising scramble decision (on 3-31 @ 1:08 pm) or my opponent to conduct the battle (on 4-3 @ 5:26 am) seems like an unnecessary delay. -
I did not bump out as the rules allow, because I wanted to AetV one final chance to continue our game at a reasonable pace. For example, the following delays seem unnecessary–
*waiting from 3-15 @11:03 am for an opponent to take his turn on 3-18 @ 12:01 pm (no bump);
*waiting 2.5 days after making a non-surprising scramble decision (on 3-31 @ 1:08 pm) for my opponent to conduct the battle (on 4-3 @ 5:26 am);- waiting 6 days (4-6 @ 9:41 am to 4-12 @ 11:02 am) for a weaken and nearly broke Italy to take its turn.
I offered to continue our interesting game if we could play without unnecessary delays. The bump rules are in place to keep games going at a reasonable pace. It is not unsporting to expect an opponent to adhere to the rules.
Suggested Topics
