I am astonished no one mentioned Fortress America, the old Gamemaster Series game from back in the 1980s. My friends and I have played it twice in the last several weeks and both times, it was down to the wire (America won both times – BARELY the second time around). It’s a great game because you can play it in under 3 hours, the combat system requires more subtlety and ingenuity than other games, and the outcome usually is in doubt up until the very end.
But anyway, my list right now would be:
1. Fortress America
2. A&A Minis
3. A Game of Thrones
4. A&A Revised
5. Battlestar Galactica
But gaming online has definitely taken a back seat to gaming live, now that I finally have a local gaming group once again! :D