The new forum has been a lot of work and it's not done yet

[djensen]

@Private-Panic I’m waiting on a feature in the next NodeBB that would allow me to turn off ads for member. I still need to acknowledge the Gold/Silver/Bronze sponsors but Google ads would be turned off. Maybe paid members get to use signatures?

Thanks for the ideas. Like you said, I can’t take stuff away but I’m looking for ways to improve the offering for paid members so it feels more like a subscription.

I’ll have to comb through your ideas, some great thoughts in there.

[djensen]

@Panther You’ve done and continue to do an amazing job as moderator!

[djensen]

@redrum said in The new forum has been a lot of work and it's not done yet:

My only advice is don’t burn yourself out as its already to a good place and the remaining todos can be slowly knocked off.

Why does it usually take somebody else to point out burn out? That’s exactly what this is.

I think I was so worried about losing members and traffic that I kept pushing until it was good enough and it didn’t quite get there (or so I thought). I guess it turns out, it is good enough. Thanks!

[djensen]

@aequitas-et-veritas Have you seen the new “replies” icon on the navigation bar? Does that help find your games?

[aequitas-et-veritas]

@djensen yupp, it makes a difference now.
I like it.
👍🏽🙌🏽

[Midnight_Reaper]

@djensen,

Thanks for all you’ve done over the years. And thanks for working so hard at getting this software conversion done. If you need to take a breather, then please do so. Burning yourself out over this won’t help anyone.

The forum is serviceable in it’s current condition. Is it perfect? No, but the old forum’s software wasn’t perfect either. Relax, recharge, and then come back, ready to go. We’ll still be here.

-Midnight_Reaper

[djensen]

@aequitas-et-veritas Only problem is that the list eventually gets truncated. What we need is a list of watched topics, sorted by unread.

[djensen]

@aequitas-et-veritas I think I found what you and the rest of the community are looking for:

Nav Bar > Recent (clock icon) > All Topics (select box top right) > Select “Watched Topics”

The problem is that this setting is not sticky. So you’ll have to set it again the next time. Personally, I’ll be using this a lot more.

[Panther]

@djensen said in The new forum has been a lot of work and it's not done yet:

@aequitas-et-veritas Only problem is that the list eventually gets truncated. What we need is a list of watched topics, sorted by unread.

A workaround for the “Unread-List” on a category level is to set “Ignoring”:

or on a topics-level to set “Ignoring”:

In this context, these checkboxes to be found in the “Settings” are relevant, too:

This allows for effectively filtering what is part of the Unread-List.

[simon33]

One thing I really don’t like about the new forum is that it allows you to post if there has been a reply and even shows you the thread again omitting someone else’s reply. Is it possible to do something about that?

[djensen]

@simon33 It shouldn’t do that. Actually what it should be doing is automatically adding the intermediate post (no refresh required) to the end of the topic whole you’re working. I think it even gives you a notification in the lower right side.

You should think of the post composer as independent of the topic. You can actually navigate away from the topic and continue to compose. You can also start a post and minimize it and come back later. You can even close your browser and come back and your unfinished post will be there.

What browser are you using?

[simon33]

Firefox on Ubuntu 18.04 64 bit.

[barnee]

Your work is appreciated dj. Sorry if you had a bad day. Thought the transition was going pretty good.

Obviously this isn’t a money maker. Most people don’t make $200 bucks an hour. Life is too short to be unhappy.

Take a break or bag it. Triplea is the reason a lot of people are here.

Anyway, good thoughts and good things for all : )

[simon33]

@djensen said in The new forum has been a lot of work and it's not done yet:

@simon33 It shouldn’t do that. Actually what it should be doing is automatically adding the intermediate post (no refresh required) to the end of the topic whole you’re working. I think it even gives you a notification in the lower right side.

You should think of the post composer as independent of the topic. You can actually navigate away from the topic and continue to compose. You can also start a post and minimize it and come back later. You can even close your browser and come back and your unfinished post will be there.

What browser are you using?

Perhaps the Triple-A forum poster bypasses this? I’ve seen the popup but I’m not sure what happens if someone posts to a thread you’re reading and you don’t click the popup.

[djensen]

@barnee I may have exaggerated a bit to make a point :grinning: . I don’t make $200/hour either. Not yet. ;-)

[The Pripet Martian]

@djensen While I’m still adjusting to the new forums, I think this was a good move. As far as monetizing the site…while I don’t know much about such things, making TripleA a pay-to-play service seems to me to be a good place to start. For example, TripleA access could be included for Bronze, Silver and Gold Patrons, while non-patrons pay $2/month or $20/year. Obviously, becoming a Bronze Patron would be the smart play in that scenario; either way, the objective is met.

Beyond that, I think a slightly more aggressive approach to the support drive is warranted. I’m sure you don’t want to spam everyone who visits the site (and everyone hates spam), but increasing the prominence of the message that this site runs primarily on donations wouldn’t hurt. Perhaps a weekly newsletter, similar to the Digest sent out on 18 NOV and featuring links to the top-five discussion topics of the past seven days, could include a prominent message about the support drive.

I find A&A.org an invaluable site and worthy of my financial support, which is why I became a Silver Patron several months ago. I encourage others to do the same, as there’s no better place for we A&A addicts to congregate with our own kind.

[djensen]

@The-Pripet-Martian Great ideas. I don’t think I can make TripleA pay to play without killing the community. Maybe I can limit the number of active games though. But even then, people would just go elsewhere. Another alternative is that games with non-patrons get deleted when inactive for x-months. Everybody else’s games stay forever?

[redrum]

@djensen Well unless we added similar limitations for the TripleA forums, I imagine most folks would just migrate their PBF games there if you added any limitations here since its essentially equivalent PBF functionality (and now very similar forum functionality as a whole).

[Whackamatt]

@djensen

Thanks a million for all of the hard work! I’ve certainly enjoyed the website over these past many years!

I do have one suggestion for the site. My apologies if this has been brought up before.

Is there a way to have a some kind of indicator when viewing a forum page that marks which threads I’ve posted in? It was my primary method for identifying which game threads were mine. It’s quite cumbersome for my old eyes to try and read through all of the game descriptions for my name or the right team game thread. On the old site I’d simply scan for that icon denoting I had posted in it, and it had to be my game in the forums.

Thanks again for all the hard work! I know what seem like simple suggestions often involve a lot of coding behind the scenes.

-Whack

[simon33]

Hi whack,
The bell icon in the top right is what you are looking for.